The Record · every verdict, nothing deleted

What we said, and what happened next

Every X-Ray verdict we have published, the price on the day we wrote it, and how the share has done against the S&P 500 since. The calls that went wrong stay on this page next to the ones that went right.

Benchmark: S&P 500 (SPY), same days
The record couldn't be loaded right now. Please try again in a few minutes.

How a call is scored

An Own / Accumulate call worked if the share beat the S&P 500 from the day we wrote it. A Pass / Too hard call worked if the share did worse than the index, because staying out was the better choice. Hold / Wait calls are shown but not scored: they say "not now", not "buy" or "sell". Calls younger than 7 days are listed and left out of the totals. Each report's position is fixed on the day it is published.

What the numbers are

Price return only, dividends not included, for the share and the index alike. "Price then" is the close on or before the publication date, adjusted for splits. This is a public record of published opinions, not a recommendation or a model portfolio. Full method on the methodology page.