Total shareholder return, decomposed
An owner's return comes from the dividend, the buyback, growth in earnings and a change in what the market will pay for them. Splitting a past return this way tells you how much of it could happen again.
Where a share's return comes from
Total shareholder return (TSR) is the change in the share price plus the dividends, usually assumed reinvested. The price part can be taken apart, because a share price is earnings per share times the price-to-earnings multiple, and earnings per share is total earnings divided by the number of shares.
So the price can rise because the company earns more, because there are fewer shares to split the earnings between, or because the market pays a higher multiple. Add the dividend and you have the whole return.
The parts really multiply rather than add, which is why it's an approximation. For returns of a few per cent a year the sum is close enough. John Bogle used a shorter version for the market as a whole: dividend yield plus earnings growth was the investment return, and the change in P/E was the speculative return.
Five years of Brockley Foods
Brockley Foods (illustrative) starts at $50 a share, on earnings of $2.50 and a P/E of 20. It pays half its earnings as dividends, a 2.5% yield. Over five years net income grows 5% a year and the share count falls 2% a year. By the end, the market will only pay 16 times earnings.
Now the exact version. EPS grows (1.05 ÷ 0.98) − 1 = 7.1% a year and ends at about $3.53. At 16 times that, the price is about $56.48, a gain of 2.5% a year. The dividend yield drifts up as the P/E falls, from 2.5% to about 3.1%, and with dividends reinvested the total comes to about 5.4% a year.
The sum came in about a quarter of a point short, mostly because the yield rose along the way. The story is still right: a decent business held back by a market that cooled on it.
Same return, different quality
The split earns its keep when two returns look alike.
Company X earned its 10% from cash and growth, which can carry on. Company Y earned most of its return because investors now pay a third more for each dollar of profit, and a P/E can't rise 6% a year for ever. That's Faber's case for shareholder yield in one table: the dividend and the buyback are the parts a company pays you directly.
Running the sum forward
The same sum is a rough way to think about the future, as long as you're honest about the inputs. Take a company with a 2% dividend yield and a 1.5% net buyback yield, whose earnings you think can grow 4% a year, on a P/E of 25 today. If the P/E drifts back to 20 over ten years, that's (20 ÷ 25)^(1/10) − 1, about −2.2% a year.
Add them up: 2 + 1.5 + 4 − 2.2 ≈ 5.3% a year. Only the two yields are firm. Growth is a guess and the multiple a bigger one. DL 203 uses a shorter cousin of this, yield plus dividend growth. Treat the result as a sense check, never a forecast.
When the decomposition misleads
- Odd start or end points. If earnings were depressed in the first year by a recession or a one-off charge, earnings growth looks huge and the multiple looks as though it collapsed. Cyclical companies need normal-year earnings at both ends.
- Growth bought with shares. A company that doubles its earnings by issuing stock for an acquisition shows strong earnings growth and a negative buyback yield. The sum handles that properly, as long as you include the dilution.
- Growth bought with debt. Borrowing to buy a rival lifts earnings growth and adds risk the sum can't see. Look at the balance sheet alongside it.
- Big numbers. The sum drifts away from the exact figure as the parts get bigger. Above 15% or 20% a year, multiply instead: (1 + growth) × (1 + buyback) × (1 + change in P/E) − 1, then add the dividend yield.
The decomposition card on Dividend Line
The Business & Competitors tab has a Total Return Decomposition card that does this over five years for the company and its peers. TSR is today's price plus the dividends per share paid over five years, divided by the price five years ago and annualised, without reinvesting the dividends. The buyback bar is the annual fall in the diluted share count over the last five fiscal years. The earnings bar is the growth of total earnings: EPS growth with that share-count effect taken out, so the buyback is counted once. The dividend bar is the five years of dividends divided by five, as a percentage of today's price. The change in multiple is whatever's left: TSR minus the other three.
That's the split from this lesson. A company retiring 3% of its shares a year with EPS up 10% shows about 7% in the earnings bar and 3% in the buyback bar. A company that issues shares shows a negative buyback bar and an earnings bar that's higher than its EPS growth.
A Long-Run Performance table below it gives TSR over one, three, five and ten years for the same companies.
Takeaways
Sources for this lesson
- John C. Bogle, The Little Book of Common Sense Investing (2007)
- Meb Faber, Shareholder Yield: A Better Approach to Dividend Investing (2013)