Dividends + buybacks + debt paydown
A dividend yield only counts the cash that lands in your account. Companies also pay their owners by retiring shares and by paying off lenders. Add them up and some high yielders look a lot less generous.
Cash leaves a company by more than one door
Picture a company with $800 million of free cash flow. Management can send some of it to you as a dividend. It can buy back shares, so each share you still hold is a bigger slice of the business. Or it can repay lenders, which leaves more of the company's value with its owners and less with its banks.
Only the first of those shows up in the dividend yield. A company that pays no dividend and spends a fortune on buybacks has a yield of zero. A company that borrows to keep a fat dividend going can look generous right up to the cut. Shareholder yield tries to see past both.
Two versions of the same idea
The idea goes back at least to William Priest and Lindsay McClelland's 2007 book Free Cash Flow and Shareholder Yield. Meb Faber's short 2013 book, Shareholder Yield, took it to individual investors. He counted debt paydown too, and his US backtests found that ranking stocks on the total beat ranking them on dividend yield alone.
Most data sites, this one included, stop at dividends plus net buybacks, so ask which version you're looking at. And check for the word net. Lesson 2 is about what happens when it's missing.
A 2.5% yielder and a 6% yielder
Two illustrative companies, one year of cash flows each.
Hatherley handed back $750 million, about 94% of its free cash flow, and only a third of it arrived as dividends. A dividend screen set at 3% would never have shown it to you.
Free cash flow covered $400 million of Cresswell's dividend. The rest, and $320 million of new spectrum licences, was paid for by borrowing and selling new shares. Owners got 6% in cash and gave most of it back as more debt and a smaller slice each.
Why a dividend investor should care
A dividend is cash you can spend. A buyback isn't, and if you live on your portfolio that matters (DL 203's living on dividends lesson is built around it). Buybacks still count toward what you earn as an owner. Every share retired raises your claim on future profits and future dividends.
Boards treat the dividend as a promise and the buyback as a dial, so buybacks are usually cut first in a bad year. A company that pays a well-covered dividend and does the rest through buybacks can halve the buyback before anyone talks about the dividend. Taxes on the two also differ from country to country, which is one reason companies lean on one more than the other.
In most recent years, S&P 500 companies have spent more on buybacks than on dividends, so dividend yield alone misses the larger share of what many American companies return. Our buybacks guide covers the basics.
When the total misleads
- One year is noise. Buybacks come in bursts and debt repayments follow maturity dates, so a single year's shareholder yield can double or vanish for no lasting reason. Average three to five years.
- Who forced it? Debt repaid because the lenders demanded it isn't a gift to owners. Find out why before you add it to the yield. Financial Fortress covers what a healthy debt load looks like.
- Cash it didn't earn. A shareholder yield above free cash flow year after year is being paid for somehow, usually with debt. The coverage checks in Dividend Mastery work just as well on the total.
- Banks and insurers. Borrowing is raw material for a bank, so a debt paydown yield tells you nothing there. Stick to dividends and net buybacks for financials.
Shareholder yield on Dividend Line
The Dividends tab of a company page ends its top panel with a Shareholder yield band for the last twelve months. The dividend part is the tab's trailing yield, dividends per share over the price. The buyback part is net: cash spent on repurchases minus cash received from issuing shares, from the cash flow statement, turned into a yield by comparing it with dividends paid. A label sums up the mix as Dividend-led, Balanced, Buyback-led or Net issuer, the last when the company issued more stock than it bought back.
For a company that hasn't paid a dividend in three years or more, the tab shows a Net Buyback Yield (net buybacks over market value) instead.
Debt paydown isn't in either figure. To add Faber's third part, open the Financials tab and find the Net Debt Issuance row in the cash flow statement. A negative number means the company repaid more than it borrowed that year. Divide the repayment by market value and add it to the band. The row covers a fiscal year and the band the last twelve months, so treat the total as rough.
Takeaways
Sources for this lesson
- William Priest and Lindsay McClelland, Free Cash Flow and Shareholder Yield (2007)
- Meb Faber, Shareholder Yield: A Better Approach to Dividend Investing (2013)
- S&P Dow Jones Indices, quarterly S&P 500 buyback and dividend reports