Gross vs net buybacks: dilution
A company can spend billions on its own shares and still end the year with nearly as many as it started with. Where the new shares come from, three ways to net them out, and the one number that settles it.
What the press release counts
When a company says it bought back $2 billion of stock, that's gross: the cash that went out of the door. Over the same year, shares were almost certainly coming in the other way, from:
- Employee pay. Restricted stock units, options and share purchase plans all create new shares. In technology this is often the biggest source by far.
- Acquisitions paid for in stock. The seller receives new shares, and the cash flow statement shows nothing.
- Capital raises, and convertible bonds that turn into shares.
Net buybacks are what's left once those come off. Only the net figure changes the size of your slice.
A 4% buyback that shrank the company by 1%
Varga Software (illustrative) starts the year with 1,000 million shares at $50, a market value of $50 billion. To keep the arithmetic clean, the price stays at $50 all year and all employee stock comes as restricted stock units, which staff receive free when they vest.
The press release says $2 billion. Three-quarters of it went on replacing shares handed to staff, which is really a cost of paying employees. The owners' slice grew by about 1%.
Three ways to net, and why they disagree
There are three common ways to get from gross to net. They give Varga different answers, and the reason is worth knowing.
In real accounts the first method does catch cash from employees exercising options or buying through a purchase plan. It still misses every restricted unit, now the most common way big companies pay in stock. If you only check one thing, check the share count. It doesn't care how the shares were created.
Shares issued for a deal
Suppose that the next year Varga buys a smaller rival and pays with 20 million new shares, worth $1 billion. No cash moves, so nothing appears in the financing section of the cash flow statement. The share count jumps by about 2%.
That isn't automatically bad. Varga got a business in return, and if it's worth more than $1 billion the remaining owners come out ahead. It's still a purchase paid for with your ownership. A net buyback built from the share count shows it as negative that year, which is honest. One built from cash flows misses it.
Dilution across the whole market
The same leak shows up across the whole stock market. In a 2003 paper with a title that gives away the answer, "Earnings Growth: The Two Percent Dilution", William Bernstein and Robert Arnott argued that new shares (from companies listing for the first time as well as from existing ones selling more stock) had held earnings-per-share growth for existing investors about two percentage points a year below the growth of the economy.
A company that keeps issuing adds to that leak, and its owners need faster business growth just to stand still per share.
When the share count misleads
- Averages lag. Most data uses the weighted average share count for the year, so a big buyback in December barely moves this year's figure and turns up in next year's. Compare several years.
- Diluted counts move with the price. The diluted figure includes options that are worth exercising, so a rising share price can add shares on paper with no new stock issued.
- Splits. A two-for-one split doubles the count overnight. Check the old years were adjusted before you read a doubling as dilution.
- Grant-date values. Stock-based compensation is booked at the share price on the day of the grant. If the price doubles before the units vest, the expense understates what the shares cost the owners.
Gross and net on Dividend Line
The site shows both kinds of number, and they can differ a lot. The Dividends tab's shareholder yield, from lesson 1, is net on a cash basis: repurchases minus cash received from issuing shares. That's the first method in the table, so it catches option exercises and capital raises but not restricted stock.
The buyback yields on the Buybacks tab, in the Summary tab's Dividend & Buybacks group and in the Financials tab's Capital Allocation rows are gross: cash spent on repurchases divided by market value. The Total Shareholder Yield at the top of the Buybacks tab adds dividends paid to that gross figure, so for a company that pays heavily in stock it will sit well above the Dividends tab's number.
For the net picture, use the Buybacks tab. Its Buybacks vs Stock-Based Compensation card sets the last twelve months of repurchases against stock-based pay, shows the difference as Net Real Buyback, and labels the ratio between them: 3× or more is Genuinely accretive, 1.2× to 3× a Modest net buyback, and anything lower Cosmetic only. Further up, Shares CAGR and Cumulative Reduction track the diluted share count over up to 15 years, and the Net Buyback / Dilution per Year chart shows each year's change in shares.
Takeaways
Sources for this lesson
- William Bernstein and Robert Arnott, "Earnings Growth: The Two Percent Dilution", Financial Analysts Journal (2003)
- Meb Faber, Shareholder Yield: A Better Approach to Dividend Investing (2013)