DL 363 · Peter Lynch: Invest in What You Know · Lesson 1 of 5

The six categories of stock

Lynch's first question about any stock was what kind of company it is. The answer tells you what to expect from it and how much it's sensible to pay.

Level:Intermediate
◆
Read time:5 min
◆
Course:DL 363
The investor

A fund manager who went to the mall

Peter Lynch took over Fidelity's Magellan fund in 1977, when it managed about $18 million. When he stepped down in 1990, at 46, it held around $14 billion and had returned about 29% a year on average. At about 29% a year, money grows more than 25-fold in 13 years. Very few public funds have done anything like it over a stretch that long.

Then he wrote One Up on Wall Street (1989) for ordinary investors. Its big claim was that amateurs have an edge over professionals, because they run into good businesses early, at the shopping centre or in their own kitchen. That part became famous. The rest of the book, which is mostly about the research you do after you notice something, got far less attention.

The research starts with one plain question. What kind of company is this?

The framework

Six kinds of company

Lynch sorted every stock into one of six groups. Each group comes with its own expectations, and a price that's sensible for one would be silly for another.

CategoryEarnings growthWhat you hope forWhat usually goes wrong
Slow growersAbout as fast as the economyA steady, well-covered dividendPaying a growth price for a mature business
StalwartsRoughly 10–12% a yearA solid gain over a few years, and shelter in bad marketsBuying when the P/E is far above its usual range
Fast growersRoughly 20–25% a yearSeveral times your money, sometimes tenfoldGrowth stops and the P/E collapses with it
CyclicalsUp and down with the economyA big gain if you buy near the bottom of the cycleBuying at the top, when profits peak
TurnaroundsLittle or none, often lossesA recovery the market has written offThe recovery never comes
Asset playsBeside the pointSomething valuable the market has overlookedThe value stays hidden, or debt gets to it first

Slow growers are big companies in industries that grew up long ago. Lynch didn't own many, and when he did it was for the dividend. Stalwarts are large, well-known names still growing at a decent pace. He always kept some, mainly because they held up better than most stocks in crashes and recessions.

Fast growers were his favourite hunting ground. These are smaller, aggressive companies growing earnings by a fifth or more each year, and they don't need to be in an exciting industry. A restaurant chain or a retailer copying a winning format into one new town after another will do nicely. He got wary when growth ran well above 25%, since few businesses keep that up and the share price usually assumes they will.

Turnarounds are companies that have been knocked flat and may or may not get up again. Chrysler, close to bankruptcy at the start of the 1980s, became one of Magellan's largest positions as it recovered. Asset plays are companies sitting on something worth more than the market notices, such as a pile of cash or land still carried at what it cost decades ago.

The cyclical P/E trap
With a cyclical, a low P/E is often a warning. Profits are highest at the top of the cycle, so the P/E looks lowest exactly when the next downturn is closest. It also works the other way round: near the bottom, when profits have almost vanished, a cyclical can look absurdly expensive.
Worked example

Sorting four companies

Four invented companies, with the numbers you'd see on a company page.

Company (illustrative)EPS growthDividend yieldP/EWhat else you knowCategory
Halden Gas3% a year for 5 years5.0%13Regulated utility, no new territorySlow grower
Corrick Consumer10% a year for 5 years2.5%19Household brands sold in 80 countriesStalwart
Pinecrest Fitness24% a year for 5 yearsNone26140 gyms, opening 35 a yearFast grower
Bramwell Steel+60% last year1.5%6Steel prices at a ten-year highCyclical

Once you've named the category, you know which number to look at next, and it's a different number each time. For Halden it's whether the dividend is covered. For Corrick it's today's P/E against its own history. For Pinecrest it's how many more towns can support a gym, and whether new gyms earn as much as the old ones (35 openings on a base of 140 is 25% more gyms in a year).

Bramwell is the one to be careful with. A P/E of 6 looks like a bargain, but the 60% jump came from steel prices, and steel prices at a ten-year high are a fact about the cycle. The useful question is what Bramwell earns in an average year.

Where it breaks

Companies change category

The categories aren't permanent. Fast growers run out of towns and turn into stalwarts. Stalwarts age into slow growers. The costly mistake is to keep paying a fast-grower price after the company has moved down a group.

Worked example
A fast grower slows down (illustrative)
P/E when growth was 25% a year30
Earnings growth this year+10%
P/E the market will now pay18
Change in share price1.10 × 18 ÷ 30 = 0.66, a fall of 34%

Earnings went up and the shareholders still lost a third of their money. The business was fine. It had just stopped belonging to the category the price was built on.

Some companies also fit two groups at once. A cyclical can be an asset play, and a turnaround can own valuable property. That's fine. What Lynch cared about was that you know which story you're betting on, because that's what you'll check later.

On Dividend Line
The Summary tab of any company page shows several years of revenue and earnings growth, which is usually enough for a first guess at the category. Our how to analyze a company lesson covers what to read after that.
Remember

Takeaways

“
Key takeaway
  • Lynch's six categories: slow growers, stalwarts, fast growers, cyclicals, turnarounds and asset plays.
  • The category tells you what to expect and which number matters most for that company.
  • For cyclicals, a low P/E at peak profits is usually a warning sign.
  • Companies move between categories, and the price falls hard when a fast grower turns into a stalwart.
Sources

Sources for this lesson

  • Peter Lynch with John Rothchild, One Up on Wall Street (1989), Part II
Next lesson · DL 363 · 2 of 5 ◆

The two-minute drill

Before buying, Lynch wanted to be able to say in about two minutes why he owned the stock and what had to happen for it to work. A lot of bad purchases fail that test in the first thirty seconds.
Continue
Educational disclaimer · This content is for educational and informational purposes only. It does not constitute investment advice, tax advice, legal advice, or a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Always conduct your own research before making investment decisions.