The six categories of stock
Lynch's first question about any stock was what kind of company it is. The answer tells you what to expect from it and how much it's sensible to pay.
A fund manager who went to the mall
Peter Lynch took over Fidelity's Magellan fund in 1977, when it managed about $18 million. When he stepped down in 1990, at 46, it held around $14 billion and had returned about 29% a year on average. At about 29% a year, money grows more than 25-fold in 13 years. Very few public funds have done anything like it over a stretch that long.
Then he wrote One Up on Wall Street (1989) for ordinary investors. Its big claim was that amateurs have an edge over professionals, because they run into good businesses early, at the shopping centre or in their own kitchen. That part became famous. The rest of the book, which is mostly about the research you do after you notice something, got far less attention.
The research starts with one plain question. What kind of company is this?
Six kinds of company
Lynch sorted every stock into one of six groups. Each group comes with its own expectations, and a price that's sensible for one would be silly for another.
Slow growers are big companies in industries that grew up long ago. Lynch didn't own many, and when he did it was for the dividend. Stalwarts are large, well-known names still growing at a decent pace. He always kept some, mainly because they held up better than most stocks in crashes and recessions.
Fast growers were his favourite hunting ground. These are smaller, aggressive companies growing earnings by a fifth or more each year, and they don't need to be in an exciting industry. A restaurant chain or a retailer copying a winning format into one new town after another will do nicely. He got wary when growth ran well above 25%, since few businesses keep that up and the share price usually assumes they will.
Turnarounds are companies that have been knocked flat and may or may not get up again. Chrysler, close to bankruptcy at the start of the 1980s, became one of Magellan's largest positions as it recovered. Asset plays are companies sitting on something worth more than the market notices, such as a pile of cash or land still carried at what it cost decades ago.
Sorting four companies
Four invented companies, with the numbers you'd see on a company page.
Once you've named the category, you know which number to look at next, and it's a different number each time. For Halden it's whether the dividend is covered. For Corrick it's today's P/E against its own history. For Pinecrest it's how many more towns can support a gym, and whether new gyms earn as much as the old ones (35 openings on a base of 140 is 25% more gyms in a year).
Bramwell is the one to be careful with. A P/E of 6 looks like a bargain, but the 60% jump came from steel prices, and steel prices at a ten-year high are a fact about the cycle. The useful question is what Bramwell earns in an average year.
Companies change category
The categories aren't permanent. Fast growers run out of towns and turn into stalwarts. Stalwarts age into slow growers. The costly mistake is to keep paying a fast-grower price after the company has moved down a group.
Earnings went up and the shareholders still lost a third of their money. The business was fine. It had just stopped belonging to the category the price was built on.
Some companies also fit two groups at once. A cyclical can be an asset play, and a turnaround can own valuable property. That's fine. What Lynch cared about was that you know which story you're betting on, because that's what you'll check later.
Takeaways
Sources for this lesson
- Peter Lynch with John Rothchild, One Up on Wall Street (1989), Part II