When to sell a stalwart
Lynch owned stalwarts for steady gains and for shelter in bad markets, and sold them once the price had run ahead of the earnings. Here's how to tell when that has happened, and when selling is the mistake.
What stalwarts are for
Stalwarts are the big, familiar companies growing earnings around 10–12% a year. Lynch didn't expect tenbaggers from them. He wrote that he'd typically take a gain of 30 to 50 percent and then move the money into another stalwart that hadn't had its run yet.
He also kept some for a defensive reason. People keep buying soap and soft drinks in a recession, so these companies' earnings hold up and their shares usually fall less than the market in a crash. That makes them a reasonable place to keep part of a portfolio. It doesn't make them worth any price.
Signs a stalwart has had its run
Lynch's list of reasons to sell a stalwart was about the business and the price together. In our own words:
- The P/E has climbed well above the company's normal range, while growth hasn't sped up to justify it.
- The new products or new markets meant to drive the next few years are disappointing.
- Growth is slowing, and profits are being held up by cost cutting more than by selling more.
- The company is buying businesses it doesn't understand. Lynch's word for this was "diworseification".
- Nobody inside the company has bought shares for a long time.
One signal on its own is a reason to look harder. The first one, together with any of the others, is usually the moment Lynch would have started selling.
A stalwart that got ahead of itself
The business has done exactly what you hoped, with 10% growth a year. The share price has done much more. You're now paying 24 times earnings for a company the market has valued at 15 to 20 for a decade, and the yield sits well below its usual band, which tells you the same thing from another angle. Our Dividend Mastery course uses the same yield check.
Now look forward. Suppose growth carries on at 10% for three more years and the P/E drifts back to 18, the middle of its range. Earnings reach $4.84 × 1.1³ ≈ $6.44, and 6.44 × 18 ≈ $116. Three more years of good results would get the share price back to roughly where it is today. You'd collect the dividends and not much else.
Selling into something
Lynch's habit was to swap a stalwart that had run for another one the market hadn't rewarded yet.
Ellery is growing a little more slowly than Harrowgate, but you'd be buying it at the bottom of its range instead of above the top. Over the next three years, that difference in starting price matters more than one point of growth.
Income investors should look at one more number. The $116 from selling one Harrowgate share brings in $2.42 a year in dividends. Put into Ellery at 3.0%, the same $116 would pay about $3.48. A high yield on what you originally paid (3.8% on the $64) can hide the fact that today's money would earn more elsewhere.
When selling is the mistake
Some stalwarts deserve a higher P/E than they used to get. If a company has found a way to grow faster, or its returns on capital have risen for good, the old ten-year range is the wrong yardstick. Sell a business like that for a 50% gain and you may spend the next decade watching it from the sidelines. This is where Lynch and Buffett, who prefers to hold great companies indefinitely, part ways.
Selling also costs money. There are trading costs, and in many countries a tax bill on the gain, so the replacement has to be clearly better. Slightly cheaper won't do. Rules differ a lot between countries, so check yours before you work out the numbers.
Takeaways
Sources for this lesson
- Peter Lynch with John Rothchild, One Up on Wall Street (1989), the chapters on when to sell
- Peter Lynch with John Rothchild, Beating the Street (1993)