PEG and growth at a fair price
Lynch's quick test for whether a growth stock costs too much: compare its P/E with its growth rate. It takes ten seconds and it's easy to fool, so you need to know both halves.
A fair P/E is about the growth rate
“The p/e ratio of any company that's fairly priced will equal its growth rate.”
So a company growing earnings at 15% a year would be fairly priced at around 15 times earnings. Dividing one by the other gives the ratio most people now call PEG.
A PEG of 1 means the price matches the growth. Lynch thought a P/E of half the growth rate (a PEG of 0.5) was very attractive and one of twice the growth rate (a PEG of 2) was a bad sign. Most screens today draw the line at 1.
Why should this work at all? Over long periods a share price tends to follow earnings. If earnings grow fast and you didn't pay much for them, the price has room to rise as the earnings pile up. If you paid a huge multiple, the earnings have to grow for years just to catch up with the price.
Two growth stocks
Both companies are growing quickly, and Larkspur may well be the better business. The question is what each price asks of the future.
Say Larkspur grows 18% a year for five straight years, which would be an excellent run. Earnings per share go from $2.00 to about $4.58 (2 × 1.18⁵). If by then the market pays a Lynch-fair P/E of 18, the shares are worth about $82. You'd have watched five great years and lost roughly 8.5%.
Kestrel needs less luck. At 20% a year its earnings reach about $7.46 in five years (3 × 1.2⁵). If the P/E simply stays at 15, the shares follow earnings to about $112, roughly two and a half times what you paid.
Adding the dividend back in
Plain PEG is unfair to companies that grow slowly but pay out a lot of cash. Lynch's fix was to add the dividend yield to the growth rate and divide by the P/E. Note that this one is the right way up: higher is better.
Ashby looks unexciting on plain PEG, yet the 6% dividend lifts it into acceptable territory. Corrick, a perfectly good stalwart, fails the test at today's price. It's still a good company. The shares are simply asking a lot, which is the situation lesson 5 deals with.
What PEG can't see
PEG squeezes a business into two numbers, so it misses everything else. These are the gaps that catch people most often.
- Quality of growth. Twenty percent from new customers and 20% from acquisitions paid for with borrowed money give the same PEG. Earnings per share can also rise from buybacks while the business itself stands still.
- Debt. The P/E ignores borrowings completely. Two companies on a PEG of 0.6 can be very different bets if one owes four times its EBITDA. The Magic Formula course shows how enterprise value fixes this.
- Which growth rate? The last five years and an analyst's forecast for the next five can give wildly different answers, and forecasts lean optimistic.
- Cyclicals and rebounds. Earnings that bounce from $1 to $3 show 200% growth. On a P/E of 9 that gives a PEG of 0.045, which means nothing.
- Growth that can't last. A company growing 50% a year on a P/E of 40 has a PEG of 0.8 and looks cheap, but only if you believe 50% continues.
Lynch used the ratio as a quick filter and then did the reading. For the basics of P/E itself, see our valuation ratios lesson.
The Peter Lynch GARP screen
The screener has a Peter Lynch GARP strategy (growth at a reasonable price) that you can load in one click. It looks for a PEG between 0 and 1, earnings per share growth of at least 10% a year over five years, debt of no more than half of equity, and a return on equity of at least 15%.
Know what the PEG in that screen is made of. It's the trailing P/E divided by the five-year growth rate of diluted earnings per share, and it's left blank when that growth is zero or negative. So it describes what the company has done. Whether it keeps doing it is your call, which is where the two-minute drill comes in.
The debt and return-on-equity filters cover two of the gaps above. The dividend-adjusted ratio isn't a screener field. Add the dividend yield column and do the sum by hand for your shortlist: it takes a minute for ten companies.
Takeaways
Sources for this lesson
- Peter Lynch with John Rothchild, One Up on Wall Street (1989), the chapter on "famous numbers"