DL 340 · Moats in Depth · Lesson 4 of 5

Scale and cost advantage

Some companies win because they can make or deliver things more cheaply than anyone else. Others win because their market has room for only one. Both advantages are real, and both are more local and more fragile than they look.

Level:Advanced
◆
Read time:4 min
◆
Course:DL 340
The idea

Moats on the supply side

Morningstar's framework separates two supply-side moats. Cost advantage means producing more cheaply than rivals, through scale, a better process, a better location or a resource nobody else has. Efficient scale means serving a market that's only big enough for one or two players, so a newcomer would ruin the economics for everyone, itself included.

Scale

Relative size matters more than absolute size

Scale works through fixed costs. Spread a warehouse, a fleet of trucks or a research budget over more sales, and each sale carries less of it. What counts is size compared with competitors in the market that matters, and that market is often local. Bruce Greenwald and Judd Kahn make this point in Competition Demystified: a distributor that's dense in one region can beat a national giant spread thinly across it.

Worked example
Two distributors in one region (illustrative)
Fixed costs for each (warehouse, trucks, staff)$40M a year
Variable costs for each75% of sales
Kittredge Distribution: sales $400MEBIT 400 − 300 − 40 = $60M, a 15% margin
Ansel Supply: sales $150MEBIT 150 − 112.5 − 40 = −$2.5M
Fixed costs per dollar of sales10 cents at Kittredge, 26.7 cents at Ansel

Now let a price war start and both cut prices 5% on the same volumes. Kittredge's EBIT falls to $40 million (380 − 300 − 40), still a margin of about 10.5%. Ansel's loss widens to $10 million (142.5 − 112.5 − 40). The bigger player can set prices at a level the smaller one can't survive, and Ansel knows it, which is often enough to keep it from starting the fight.

Efficient scale

A market with room for one

Crushed stone is heavy and cheap, so hauling it far quickly costs more than the stone. A quarry's market is the area its trucks can reach at a sensible cost. Pipelines, airports and landfills have the same feature: one is enough, two is a disaster.

Worked example
Brackwater Aggregates (illustrative)
Local demand3M tonnes a year at $20 a tonne
Fixed costs$24M a year
Variable costs$6 a tonne
EBIT60 − 24 − 18 = $18M
Capital in the quarry$100M, so an 18% pre-tax return
If a rival opens and takes halfEach earns 30 − 24 − 9 = −$3M
Cost per tonne, alone vs split$14 vs $22, against a $20 price

A rival would have to spend $100 million to turn one profitable quarry into two loss-making ones. Rational rivals stay away, and Brackwater keeps earning well above its cost of capital without being especially clever.

The rest

Process, place and resource

A cheaper process is the least durable cost edge, because processes get copied. Location and unique resources last longer: a port next to the mine, a low-cost ore body, hydropower on a river nobody else can dam. The Economic Moat lesson tells the story of Dexter Shoe, where a cost position that looked solid disappeared once cheaper foreign producers arrived.

Where it breaks

When the cost edge closes

  • Technology lowers the entry ticket. Cloud computing let small software companies rent the data centres they once had to build. Online selling let small brands reach national customers without a national sales force.
  • A bigger player arrives. Local scale is no defence against a national company that decides your region is worth a few years of losses.
  • Demand grows. Brackwater's town doubles in size and suddenly there's room for two quarries.
  • The regulator takes the surplus. Efficient-scale businesses with essential services, like utilities and many pipelines, often have their returns set or capped. The moat exists; the owners just don't get to keep much of what it earns.
On Dividend Line

Reading supply-side moats on Dividend Line

Cost advantage and efficient scale are two of the six sources the Moat tab scores. Part II, Porter's Five Forces, rates the industry rather than the company, from 1 (most favourable to the incumbent) to 5 (most hostile). For an efficient-scale business, the threat of new entrants is the force to read. For a scale player, look at rivalry and the bargaining power of buyers. On most companies, the Five Forces card is a Premium section.

A scale advantage shows up as a better margin than rivals in the same market, so compare like with like. The Margins chart in the Chartroom tab puts gross, operating, net and free-cash-flow margins on one set of axes. Pull it up for the company and for its closest competitor.

Wide and narrow moats whose top-scoring source is cost advantage or efficient scale. You'll need a free account.Open the Moat Screener →
Remember

Takeaways

“
Key takeaway
  • Scale advantages come from fixed costs spread over more sales, and they depend on size relative to rivals in the same market.
  • With the same $40M of fixed costs, Kittredge earned a 15% margin and Ansel lost money. In a 5% price war, only Kittredge stayed profitable.
  • Efficient scale protects markets that can only support one player. A second quarry would have turned an 18% return into two losses.
  • Cheaper technology, a bigger entrant, growing demand and regulators can all close the gap.
Sources

Sources for this lesson

  • Bruce Greenwald and Judd Kahn, Competition Demystified (2005)
  • Heather Brilliant and Elizabeth Collins, Why Moats Matter (2014), chapters on cost advantage and efficient scale
  • Michael Porter, Competitive Strategy (1980)
Next lesson · DL 340 · 5 of 5 ◆

How moats erode: case studies

Real moats rarely get stormed head-on. More often the ground under them moves. Four well-known cases, an invented company to show what the decline looks like in the accounts, and the signs to watch.
Continue
Educational disclaimer · This content is for educational and informational purposes only. It does not constitute investment advice, tax advice, legal advice, or a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Always conduct your own research before making investment decisions.