DL 340 · Moats in Depth · Lesson 2 of 5

Five pricing-power tests

Every management team says it has pricing power. Five tests you can run from public documents to check, starting with the one most analysts stop at and going well past it.

Level:Advanced
◆
Read time:5 min
◆
Course:DL 340
The idea

One footprint isn't enough

Pricing power is the ability to charge more without losing many customers. Margins & Returns showed its best-known footprint, a gross margin that holds steady when input costs jump. That's a good test. It's also easy to fool, because margins can hold for reasons that have nothing to do with customers' loyalty.

So run several. None of the five below needs anything more exotic than an annual report and a few years of patience.

Test 1

Prices went up and volume held

Many consumer and industrial companies split their organic growth into price (often called price/mix) and volume. Read five years of it. The signature you want is price up a few per cent a year with volume flat or growing. Price up while volume falls year after year is a company harvesting its customers, which can look like strength for a long time before it stops.

Test 2

The margin through inflation

This is the DL 230 test. Find the years when the company's raw materials, energy or wages rose sharply and see what gross margin did. Then do the same for two or three competitors in the same years. A margin that held while rivals' margins fell is far stronger evidence than one that held while everyone's did.

Test 3

Prices against costs, over years

Test 2 looks at shocks. This one looks at the whole run. Compare how fast the company's prices rose with how fast its unit costs rose, over five or ten years. A company with pricing power doesn't just pass costs on. It gets a little ahead of them, year after year, and customers stay.

Worked example
Ostler Adhesives (illustrative), five years
Price per kg, year 0$10.00
Material cost per kg, year 0$4.00, so gross margin is 60%
Price after five years at +6% a year10 × 1.06⁵ = $13.38
Cost after five years at +4% a year4 × 1.04⁵ = $4.87
Gross margin, year 51 − 4.87 ÷ 13.38 = 63.6%
Volume100M kg down to 98M kg
Gross profit$600M up to $835M, +39%
If prices had only matched costs$715M, +19%

Two points a year ahead of costs, for five years, cost Ostler 2% of its volume and added about $120 million of gross profit compared with simply keeping pace.

Test 4

Who the customers are

Pricing power depends on who's across the table. Both IFRS 8 and US GAAP (ASC 280) require a company to disclose when a single customer accounts for 10% or more of revenue, so the information is usually there in the segment note.

Take Wexcombe Dairy (illustrative), which sells 35% of its output to one supermarket chain. Its gross margin may have been steady for a decade. Steady at a level the supermarket chose, though. If Wexcombe raised prices, the chain could switch suppliers or launch its own label, and Wexcombe would lose a third of its sales in one meeting. A company selling to thousands of small customers has much less to fear from any one of them.

Test 5

How big a slice of the customer's bill

Michael Porter pointed out in Competitive Strategy that buyers fight hardest over the inputs that make up a large share of their costs. Products that are cheap relative to the thing they go into, but costly if they fail, escape most of that pressure.

Worked example
Ostler's glue in a window (illustrative)
Cost to build one window$300
Ostler adhesive in it$1.50, or 0.5% of the cost
A 10% price rise on the adhesive15 cents, or 0.05% of the cost
The glass in the same window$120, or 40% of the cost

Nobody re-qualifies a new adhesive, and risks windows that leak, to save 15 cents. The glass supplier faces a purchasing manager with a spreadsheet every year.

Where it breaks

False positives

  • Mix posing as price. Price/mix rises when a company sells more of its premium range, even if no single price went up. The notes sometimes split the two. Often they don't.
  • Shortage pricing. Commodity producers raise prices when supply is tight, and margins soar. That's the market at work, and it runs in reverse when the shortage ends.
  • Power spent in advance. A company that has been getting ahead of costs for years may be borrowing from the future, opening a gap for a cheaper rival or a supermarket's own label. Falling volume is the warning (test 1).
  • Prices set by someone else. Regulated utilities, many drug makers and companies selling to governments have their prices negotiated or capped. Steady margins there say more about the regulator than the product.
On Dividend Line

The Pricing Power card

The Moat tab's Quality of the Earnings section has a Pricing Power card. It charts gross margin over up to ten fiscal years and shows the latest figure against the first and the ten-year average. The label compares the first and last years: Expanding if the margin is at least 2 points higher, Compressing if it's at least 2 points lower, Stable otherwise. When the written moat analysis has rated pricing power strong, moderate or weak, the card shows that rating and its evidence instead.

The chart also draws a dashed line at the starting margin, held flat. A company whose prices only kept pace with its costs stays on that line whatever inflation did, which is already a pass on test 2. Above it, prices outran costs; below it, costs won.

◆Analyst note
Tests 1, 4 and 5 aren't on the site. Price and volume splits, major customers and what the product does for its buyers all come from the annual report and the company's own presentations.
Remember

Takeaways

“
Key takeaway
  • Look for price rises with volume holding (test 1), a margin that held when rivals' didn't (test 2), and prices that ran ahead of unit costs for years (test 3).
  • A customer worth 10% or more of revenue must be disclosed. The bigger that customer, the less a steady margin proves.
  • Products that are a small, critical slice of the customer's cost face the least resistance. Ostler's 10% rise added 0.05% to the cost of a window.
  • Mix, shortages and regulators can all mimic pricing power. Falling volume is the clearest sign it's being used up.
Sources

Sources for this lesson

  • Michael Porter, Competitive Strategy (1980), chapter on buyer and supplier power
  • IFRS Foundation, IFRS 8 Operating Segments (information about major customers)
  • FASB, ASC 280 Segment Reporting (disclosure of major customers)
Next lesson · DL 340 · 3 of 5 ◆

Network effects and switching costs in practice

Two moats made of customers: the ones who stay because everyone else is there, and the ones who stay because leaving would hurt. How to tell a strong one from a weak one, and what a low churn rate is actually worth.
Continue
Educational disclaimer · This content is for educational and informational purposes only. It does not constitute investment advice, tax advice, legal advice, or a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Always conduct your own research before making investment decisions.