Network effects and switching costs in practice
Two moats made of customers: the ones who stay because everyone else is there, and the ones who stay because leaving would hurt. How to tell a strong one from a weak one, and what a low churn rate is actually worth.
Moats on the customer's side
Morningstar's framework lists five sources of moat: intangible assets, switching costs, network effects, cost advantage and efficient scale. Two of them live with the customer rather than in the factory. Network effects and switching costs both mean a rival with a better or cheaper product still struggles to win business, and they often turn up together.
When each new user makes it better
A network effect exists when a product gets more useful as more people use it. A messaging app is the plain case. Two-sided networks are more common in investing: a card network is worth more to shoppers as more shops accept it, and worth more to shops as more shoppers carry it. Marketplaces work the same way with buyers and sellers.
They vary enormously in strength. Two questions sort most of them.
- How far does the network reach? A ride-hailing service with lots of drivers in one city does nothing for a rider in another, so a rival can attack city by city. A card accepted in every country helps every cardholder everywhere.
- Can users belong to two networks at once? Drivers run two apps. Sellers list on two marketplaces. When joining a second network is cheap, the first one's hold is weaker than its size suggests.
Signs in the numbers: a take rate (the share of each transaction the company keeps) that holds or rises as the network grows, marketing spend per new user that falls, and market share in the biggest markets that isn't slipping.
When leaving costs more than staying
Switching costs come in different currencies. Some are money: cancellation fees, new licences. Many are effort, like moving years of data or retraining staff. The strongest are risk. A company replacing its payroll system or a bank changing its core software can stop paying people, or stop working, if the move goes wrong. Few managers want their name on that project.
Signs in the numbers: a low churn rate (the share of customers who leave each year), net revenue retention above 100% (this year's revenue from last year's customers, divided by what they paid last year), and price rises at renewal that stick. Software companies often publish these. Many others don't, which is a reason to ask.
What churn is worth
Lanyard Payroll (illustrative) charges each customer $12,000 a year at an 80% gross margin, so a customer brings in $9,600 of gross profit a year. Lanyard loses 5% of its customers each year. A rival with the same prices and margins loses 15%. Both spend $30,000 to win a new customer, and both discount future profit at 9%.
Same product and same prices, yet after paying to win them, each new Lanyard customer is worth almost four times as much. That gap lets Lanyard outspend the rival on sales and still earn more, which is how switching costs turn into scale over time.
How these moats weaken
- Network effects run in reverse. As users leave, the product gets worse for the ones who stay, so a network that starts shrinking can shrink fast. Lesson 5 shows how a rival's network pulled users away from BlackBerry and Nokia.
- Lock-in breeds resentment. Customers who feel trapped leave at the first natural exit, such as a forced upgrade or a move to new technology they'd have to migrate to anyway.
- Switching costs protect the customers you have. If new customers start choosing a rival, the base shrinks slowly at first and then faster, while churn still looks fine.
- Rule-makers can lower the walls. Card interchange fees are capped in several regions, and data-portability rules, like the one in Europe's GDPR, make leaving easier.
Sources of advantage on Dividend Line
Part I of the Moat tab scores six sources of advantage from 0 to 5: Morningstar's five plus capital allocation. Each comes with a headline, evidence and a confidence level. The scores are written by an AI model, which is given the company's business description and its ten-year numbers and told to score weak evidence low. For most companies, the free plan shows the rating and the strongest source; Premium shows all six.
The Moat Screener's "Main source" filter picks companies by their highest-scoring source. One of its preset philosophies, Switching-cost Kings, looks for wide or narrow moats with a durability score of 65 or more and switching costs as the main source.
Takeaways
Sources for this lesson
- Heather Brilliant and Elizabeth Collins, Why Moats Matter (2014)
- Pat Dorsey, The Little Book That Builds Wealth (2008), chapters on switching costs and the network effect
- Regulation (EU) 2016/679 (GDPR), Article 20: right to data portability