DL 340 · Moats in Depth · Lesson 5 of 5

How moats erode: case studies

Real moats rarely get stormed head-on. More often the ground under them moves. Four well-known cases, an invented company to show what the decline looks like in the accounts, and the signs to watch.

Level:Advanced
◆
Read time:5 min
◆
Course:DL 340
Case 1

Kodak: the market under the moat disappeared

For most of the twentieth century Eastman Kodak dominated photographic film. Much of its profit came from film, paper and processing rather than cameras, sold under one of the best-known brands in the world. In 1975 a Kodak engineer, Steven Sasson, built one of the first digital cameras.

Kodak did sell digital cameras later. The trouble was that digital pictures need no film, and the film business was where the money was. Then phones took over from cameras too. Kodak filed for bankruptcy protection in January 2012 and came out of it a much smaller company. Its brand and its know-how in chemistry were real advantages. They protected a market that stopped existing.

Case 2

Local newspapers: the bundle came apart

Many cities ended up with a single daily paper. Readers bought it because the ads and the news were there, and advertisers paid because the readers were. Classified ads for jobs, cars and homes were a large and very profitable part of the revenue.

From the late 1990s, websites took the classifieds one category at a time, most of them free or far cheaper. Readers drifted later and more slowly. Buffett had warned in his 1991 letter that media businesses were losing economic strength. Berkshire Hathaway still bought dozens of local papers in 2012, and sold its newspaper business to Lee Enterprises in 2020. Some papers adapted by building digital subscriptions, The New York Times the best-known among them, but the old local monopoly economics didn't come back.

Cases 3 and 4

BlackBerry and Nokia: the value moved

BlackBerry (called Research In Motion until 2013) owned corporate email on the move. Its secure servers sat inside company IT departments, which gave it real switching costs, and its keyboard had devoted users. Nokia was the world's largest phone maker by volume for well over a decade, with scale in manufacturing and distribution that nobody matched.

Apple's iPhone in 2007 and Google's Android soon after moved the value from the handset to the operating system and its app store. That's where the new network effect ran: more users drew more developers, and more apps drew more users. Employees brought their own phones to work and IT departments followed them. BlackBerry stopped designing its own phones in 2016 and now sells software. Nokia sold its phone business to Microsoft in 2014 and is now mainly a maker of telecom network equipment.

The common thread
None of these moats was imaginary. Each was attached to something (film, the classified page, the handset) whose share of the customer's spending shrank. When you assess a moat, ask what it's protecting, and whether customers will still pay for that thing in ten years.
Worked example

What erosion looks like in the numbers

Saltmarsh Directories (illustrative) sells printed trade directories. Its customers are moving online. Here's how six years look.

YearVolumePriceRevenueGross marginSelling costs, % of salesROIC
1+2%+4%+6.1%70%18%28%
20%+5%+5.0%70%19%28%
3−3%+6%+2.8%69%21%26%
4−6%+3%−3.2%67%24%21%
5−9%0%−9.0%63%27%14%
6−12%−4%−15.5%58%30%7%

Volume turned first, in year 3, while price rises kept revenue growing. Selling costs crept up as the company paid more to hold on to each customer. Gross margin and ROIC barely moved until year 4. By the time ROIC was telling the story clearly, the moat had been leaking for three years.

The order is typical. Volume and the cost of winning customers move first. Margins move next. Returns on capital move last.

Where it breaks

Hindsight is cheap

Every case above looks obvious now. At the time, plenty of thoughtful people expected each of these companies to adapt, and some incumbents do. For every Kodak there are businesses whose death was announced early and never came. So don't treat every new competitor as the iPhone. Look for the signs in the Saltmarsh table, in that order, and act on evidence rather than headlines.

Price is a poor signal in both directions. A falling share price may mean the market has spotted erosion you haven't. It may also mean the market is panicking about a threat that will fade. Only the business numbers settle it.

On Dividend Line

Watching for erosion on Dividend Line

Part IV of the Moat tab, Durability Risks, names three to five threats to each moat, each with a probability (low, medium or high) and a timeframe (one to three years, three to ten, or more than ten). The masthead gives an estimate of how long the moat should last (5, 10, 20 or 30 years), and the footer says when the analysis was written. Risks and their detail are Premium for most companies.

The two cards in Quality of the Earnings help with the Saltmarsh sequence. The Pricing Power card labels a gross margin that has fallen 2 points or more over the years shown as Compressing, unless the written analysis has given pricing power its own rating. The Earnings Predictability card measures how far operating income has strayed from its trend, with growth taken out, and labels the result from Highly predictable to Volatile. Neither shows volume or selling costs, so read those in the annual report.

Wide moats the analysis expects to last 20 years or more. Pick one, read its risks, and write down the first number you'd expect to move if the moat started to leak. You'll need a free account.Open the Moat Screener →
Remember

Takeaways

“
Key takeaway
  • Kodak, local newspapers, BlackBerry and Nokia all had real advantages. The things those advantages protected lost their place in customers' spending.
  • Ask what a moat protects, and whether customers will still pay for that in ten years.
  • In the accounts, erosion usually shows in volume and the cost of winning customers first, then margins, then ROIC.
  • Hindsight makes every collapse look obvious. Act on the business numbers; headlines and the share price mislead in both directions.
Sources

Sources for this lesson

  • Warren Buffett, Berkshire Hathaway letter to shareholders (1991)
  • Eastman Kodak Company, announcement of its Chapter 11 filing (January 2012)
  • Nokia, announcement of the sale of its Devices & Services business to Microsoft (September 2013, completed April 2014)
  • BlackBerry, announcement that it would stop developing hardware in-house (September 2016)
  • Berkshire Hathaway and Lee Enterprises, announcement of the sale of BH Media Group (January 2020)
  • Clayton Christensen, The Innovator's Dilemma (1997)
Next course · DL 360 Benjamin Graham ◆

Mr. Market

You've finished this course. DL 360 starts here, about 5 minutes.
Continue
Educational disclaimer · This content is for educational and informational purposes only. It does not constitute investment advice, tax advice, legal advice, or a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Always conduct your own research before making investment decisions.