DL 340 · The Buffett Method
Moats in Depth
Calling a business a moat is easy. Showing it takes evidence: returns that stay above the cost of capital for a decade, prices that climb faster than costs, customers who don't leave. Five lessons on testing each source of advantage, and on how some famous ones were lost.
Level:Advanced
◆Lessons:5
◆Read time:25 min
By the end
What you'll be able to do
- Measure how long a company's ROIC has stayed above its cost of capital, and tell a lasting spread from a fading one with the same ten-year average.
- Run five pricing-power tests from an annual report, and explain what each one can and can't prove.
- Judge the strength of a network effect or a switching cost from the numbers a company publishes, including what churn is worth.
- Work out when size gives a real cost edge, and why a market with room for only one competitor protects whoever got there first.
- Describe how the moats of Kodak, local newspapers, BlackBerry and Nokia eroded, and name the early signs to watch in any company you own.
Syllabus
5 lessons
- 1Measuring a moat: ROIC that persistsA moat is a claim about the future. The best evidence for it is in the past: a return on capital that stayed above the cost of that capital for years, while rivals had every reason to copy it.6 min
- 2Five pricing-power testsEvery management team says it has pricing power. Five tests you can run from public documents to check, starting with the one most analysts stop at and going well past it.5 min
- 3Network effects and switching costs in practiceTwo moats made of customers: the ones who stay because everyone else is there, and the ones who stay because leaving would hurt. How to tell a strong one from a weak one, and what a low churn rate is actually worth.5 min
- 4Scale and cost advantageSome companies win because they can make or deliver things more cheaply than anyone else. Others win because their market has room for only one. Both advantages are real, and both are more local and more fragile than they look.4 min
- 5How moats erode: case studiesReal moats rarely get stormed head-on. More often the ground under them moves. Four well-known cases, an invented company to show what the decline looks like in the accounts, and the signs to watch.5 min
Sources
What this course draws on
- Michael Mauboussin and Dan Callahan, "Measuring the Moat: Assessing the Magnitude and Sustainability of Value Creation", Credit Suisse (2013)
- Michael Mauboussin, Dan Callahan and Darius Majd, The Base Rate Book, Credit Suisse (2016)
- Pat Dorsey, The Little Book That Builds Wealth (2008)
- Heather Brilliant and Elizabeth Collins, Why Moats Matter: The Morningstar Approach to Stock Investing (2014)
- Bruce Greenwald and Judd Kahn, Competition Demystified (2005)
- Michael Porter, Competitive Strategy (1980)
Educational disclaimer · This content is for educational and informational purposes only. It does not constitute investment advice, tax advice, legal advice, or a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Always conduct your own research before making investment decisions.