Operating leverage
When most of a company's costs are fixed, a small change in sales becomes a big change in profit, in both directions. How to measure it, and why the feature that makes a good year great makes a bad year awful.
Costs that move with sales, and costs that don't
Some costs rise and fall with every unit sold: materials, packaging, sales commissions, the pay of temporary staff. Others stay put whatever happens to sales, at least for a year or so. Rent, permanent salaries and the depreciation of a factory that's already built all fall in this group.
The mix matters a great deal. A company whose costs are mostly fixed has to cover them before it makes any profit at all. Once it has, each extra dollar of sales drops almost straight to operating profit. That's operating leverage.
Same sales, same profit, different cost structures
Two illustrative companies each have $1,000 million of revenue and $100 million of EBIT, an operating margin of 10%. Ashgrove Cloud runs data centres: $700 million of its costs are fixed, and variable costs are only 20% of revenue. Bramble Staffing places temporary workers. It pays them 80% of what it bills, and its fixed costs are just $100 million.
Ashgrove's good year lifted its operating margin from 10% to about 16.4%. Its bad year cut it to about 2.2%. Bramble barely noticed either, because most of its costs shrank and grew with its revenue.
Push revenue down 20%, to $800 million, and the gap gets stark. Ashgrove loses $60 million. Bramble still earns $60 million. Ashgrove breaks even at $875 million of revenue (700 ÷ 0.8), only 12.5% below where it started, while Bramble's break-even is all the way down at $500 million.
One twist. DOL isn't a fixed property of a company; it rises as profit gets thinner. At $900 million of revenue, Ashgrove's contribution is $720 million and its EBIT $20 million, so its DOL has jumped to 36. Close to break-even, tiny changes in sales swing profit wildly.
Where you'll find it
High operating leverage comes with big upfront costs and cheap extra units: software, airlines, hotels, chipmakers with their own plants, railways. It's low in businesses like staffing or wholesale distribution, where most of the cost arrives with each order.
Neither is better. High operating leverage is what lets a software company's margins climb year after year as it grows into its cost base. It's also why airline profits are so violent. A half-empty flight costs nearly as much to operate as a full one.
Debt stacks on top. Interest is another fixed cost, so a company with high operating leverage and heavy borrowing has two amplifiers in a row. The Financial Fortress, the next course in this faculty, deals with that side.
Reading operating leverage from the accounts
Companies don't tell you how much of their cost base is fixed, so you estimate it from history. In a year when sales rose 6% and EBIT rose 15%, the ratio was 15 ÷ 6 = 2.5. Work it out for several years, including at least one bad one, and you'll get a feel for the range.
Throw out years when sales barely moved. If sales rise 0.5% and EBIT 4%, the ratio comes out at 8, and almost all of that is noise.
Costs aren't really fixed or variable
The tidy split in the example is a simplification. Many costs are fixed only up to a point: a factory running flat out needs a second shift, then a second factory. Managers also cut so-called fixed costs when sales fall, by freezing hiring, closing sites or trimming bonuses, so real downturns are usually gentler than the arithmetic predicts. Some of those savings quietly come back once sales recover.
Price rises can pass for operating leverage too. If a company raises prices 5% and sells the same volume, nearly all the extra revenue reaches EBIT and the measured ratio looks huge. That's pricing power at work, which is good news of a different sort. Where the company splits its growth into price and volume, use the split.
Watching it on Dividend Line
The Margins chart in the Chartroom tab is the quickest check. If the operating margin line swings much more than the gross margin line from year to year, a lot of the costs between them are fixed. The chart's reading line also says whether the latest operating margin is a high or a low for the years shown.
For the arithmetic, the Financials tab has the annual income statements. Put revenue and operating income for each year side by side and divide one percentage change by the other. Our metrics lesson covers the margins themselves if you want a refresher.
Takeaways
Sources for this lesson
- Stephen Penman, Financial Statement Analysis and Security Valuation (5th edition, 2013)
- Aswath Damodaran, Investment Valuation (3rd edition, 2012)