Incremental ROIC and the reinvestment rate
A company's ROIC describes the capital it already has. Future value depends on the return on the next dollar, and on how many next dollars the business can put to work.
The return on the next dollar
ROIC is an average over everything a company has invested, some of it decades ago. A business with a 20% ROIC might be earning 30% on its old factories and 8% on the new ones. The average hides that, at least for a while.
Tamsin's ROIC still looks respectable at about 16%. The $600 million it added over five years is earning 10%, though, and if that carries on, the average will keep sliding toward 10%. The falling average was the clue. The incremental figure tells you where it's heading.
The reinvestment rate
It's the share of this year's operating profit that goes back into the business instead of out to owners and lenders. An illustrative company earns $200 million of NOPAT, spends $150 million on capex against $90 million of depreciation, and ties up another $20 million in working capital. Net reinvestment is 150 − 90 + 20 = $80 million, a reinvestment rate of 40%.
Growth needs both parts. A business that reinvests heavily at poor returns grows slowly. So does one with superb returns and nowhere to put new money.
High returns, slow growth
Fenwick is the better business by a distance, and Garron grows twice as fast. Fenwick's niche simply can't absorb much more capital at 40%; there are only so many new shops worth opening. That's no flaw. The cash Fenwick can't use goes to shareholders as dividends and buybacks, and they can put it to work somewhere else.
Buffett described this kind of company in his 2007 letter, with See's Candies as the example. See's needed little extra capital as it grew, and most of what it earned went to Berkshire to pay for other businesses. A great business that can't reinvest is still a great thing to own. Just don't value it as if it will grow like one that can.
Growth that destroys value
Growth only adds value when new capital earns more than it costs. The cost of capital is the return investors could expect elsewhere for similar risk. Call it 8% here.
Take an illustrative company with $100 million of NOPAT, and let it grow 4% a year forever. The return on its new capital decides how much it must reinvest to get that growth (4% divided by the return), and so how much cash is left over each year. Value it as a growing perpetuity and you get this:
At a 20% return, growth adds $750 million of value. At exactly 8%, it adds nothing: the company gets bigger and its owners are no richer. At 5%, the same 4% growth wipes out 60% of what the business was worth standing still. Sales rise, profits rise, and the owners lose.
So when a management team talks up its growth, there's one question worth asking. What return are you earning on the money it took?
Lumpy, tiny and invisible
- Lumpy investment. A new plant costs money years before it earns any. Measure incremental ROIC over three to five years, and if the business takes time to ramp up, compare NOPAT with the capital invested a year or two earlier.
- Tiny denominators. If invested capital barely changes, a modest wobble in NOPAT produces an incremental ROIC of 200%, or minus 150%. Treat numbers like that as noise.
- Invisible investment. Research, software development and brand advertising go through the income statement as expenses, so they never appear in invested capital. For asset-light companies the reinvestment rate looks too low and ROIC too high. Some analysts capitalise R&D to correct for it.
- Bought growth. Acquisitions are reinvestment. Count the full price paid, goodwill and all, or a serial acquirer will look as though it grows for free.
Checking it on Dividend Line
There's no incremental ROIC figure on the site, so this one is a job for the Financials tab and a calculator. Take operating income, tax, debt, equity and cash for two years about five years apart, and work it through as in the Tamsin example. Our free cash flow lesson shows where capex and working capital sit in the cash flow statement.
The ROIC & ROE chart in the Chartroom tab shows the direction of the average. A ROIC drifting down while the company grows is the Tamsin pattern, and often the first sign that new money is earning less than the old.
For the cost-of-capital side, the Quality of Returns card on the Business & Competitors tab sets ROIC beside an estimated cost of capital for the company and its peers. The estimate is 6% plus twice the stock's beta, kept between 4% and 14% (9% when there's no beta), so treat it as a rough sense check. The Moat Screener has a switch, Earns more than its cost of capital, that uses a flat 8% hurdle for ROIC.
Takeaways
Sources for this lesson
- Tim Koller, Marc Goedhart and David Wessels, Valuation (7th edition, 2020), chapters on the principles of value creation and return on invested capital
- Michael Mauboussin and Dan Callahan, "Calculating Return on Invested Capital", Credit Suisse (2014)
- Warren Buffett, Berkshire Hathaway letter to shareholders (2007)