DL 230 · Margins & Returns on Capital · Lesson 1 of 5

Gross margin and pricing power

Gross margin is the first profit line on the income statement and often the most revealing one. What goes into it, what a steady margin says about a business, and how it can fool you.

Level:Intermediate
◆
Read time:6 min
◆
Course:DL 230
The basics

The first cut of profit

Every sale has a direct cost attached. A furniture maker pays for timber and for the people in the workshop. A shop pays its suppliers for whatever's on the shelf. Take those costs away from revenue and you're left with gross profit, the money that has to cover everything else before the owners see a cent.

Gross margin
(Revenue − Cost of goods sold) ÷ Revenue
Cost of goods sold (COGS) also goes by cost of sales or cost of revenue.

A company with $500 million of sales and $300 million of COGS has $200 million of gross profit, a gross margin of 40%. Of every dollar a customer pays, 40 cents is left once the product itself has been paid for.

Further down come operating margin (after selling, admin and research costs) and net margin (after interest and tax too). Gross margin says the most about the product and what customers will pay for it. The lower ones say more about how the company is run.

What counts

COGS means different things in different industries

There's no universal list of what belongs in cost of goods sold. Companies make different choices even inside one industry. Roughly:

IndustryUsually in COGSUsually below gross profit
ManufacturerRaw materials, factory wages and energy, depreciation of the plantSales force, marketing, head office, research
RetailerWhat it paid suppliers for the goods, usually with inbound freightVaries: some retailers put store rent and distribution in cost of sales, others report them lower down
Software companyHosting and data centres, customer support, third-party licencesResearch and development, sales and marketing
Bank or insurerUsually no gross profit line at alln/a

Two more traps. Under IFRS, the international accounting standards, a company may present its costs by nature (raw materials, staff costs, depreciation) instead of by function, and then there's no gross profit line to read. And companies sometimes move a cost across the line, shipping or a slice of depreciation, say, which shifts gross margin while nothing changes in the business. Before comparing two companies, read how each one defines cost of sales in its accounting policies.

Why investors care

A steady gross margin is a clue to pricing power

“The single most important decision in evaluating a business is pricing power.”
Warren Buffett, interview with the Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission (2010)

Pricing power is the ability to pass on higher costs, or raise prices faster than inflation, without losing many customers. You can't see it directly. You can see its footprint: a gross margin that stays high and holds steady through years when input costs jump around.

The reason is mechanical. If a company's costs rise 10% and it can lift prices to match, its gross margin barely moves. If it can't, the margin gets squeezed, and the thinner the margin was to begin with, the harder the squeeze hits profit.

Worked example

One cost shock, two outcomes

Two illustrative companies each sell $1,000 million a year. Brindle Foods makes branded sauces at a 60% gross margin. Dorn Packaging makes plain cardboard boxes at 20%. In the same year, the cost of their inputs goes up 10%.

Worked example
Brindle Foods (illustrative)
Revenue and COGS before$1,000M and $400M
Price rise10%
Volume lost2%
New revenue1,000 × 1.10 × 0.98 = $1,078M
New COGS400 × 1.10 × 0.98 = $431.2M
Gross profit$646.8M, up 7.8%
Gross margin60.0%, unchanged

A few shoppers grumbled and switched. Most kept buying the sauce they liked. The margin held, and because it now applied to a bigger revenue figure, gross profit in dollars went up.

Worked example
Dorn Packaging (illustrative)
Revenue and COGS before$1,000M and $800M
Price riseNone. Customers buy boxes on price and rivals didn't move
New COGS800 × 1.10 = $880M
Gross profit$120M, down 40%
Gross margin12.0%, down from 20%

Same shock. Dorn lost 40% of its gross profit in a year, before paying a single dollar of overhead.

Twenty per cent can be a perfectly healthy margin for a box maker. What tells you about pricing power is how the margin behaves when costs move, so look at ten years, and look hardest at the years when input prices jumped.

The evidence

Gross profit and share returns

In a 2013 paper, Robert Novy-Marx showed that US companies with high gross profit relative to their total assets went on to earn higher stock returns than those with low gross profit, with about the same predictive power as the better-known value effect. His argument: gross profit is the cleanest accounting measure of real profitability, because it sits above most of the judgement calls made further down the income statement.

Where it breaks

When a good margin tells a false story

  • Cheaper inputs. When raw materials fall in price, a company's gross margin can rise for a year or two with no pricing power behind it. Check whether its competitors' margins rose at the same time.
  • Mix. Sell more of the premium line and less of the basic one, and gross margin rises even if each product's margin stayed flat. It works in reverse too. The segment note in the annual report usually lets you split this out.
  • A margin spent below the line. Plenty of software and drug companies have gross margins above 70% and still lose money, because research and selling costs eat the lot. Operating margin, in the next lesson, is closer to what owners keep.
  • A margin that invites rivals. A very high gross margin in a business that's easy to enter rarely lasts. Ten steady years say more than one excellent one.
On Dividend Line

Gross margin on Dividend Line

On a company page, The Moat tab has a Pricing Power card under Quality of the Earnings. It charts gross margin year by year, sets the latest figure beside the one from a decade earlier, shows the ten-year average, and labels the trend Expanding, Stable or Compressing. Where the written moat analysis has its own pricing-power rating, the card shows that instead.

The Chartroom tab has a Margins chart in its Franchise chapter, with gross, operating, net and free-cash-flow margins on the same axes. Its one-line reading calls gross margin stable when it has stayed within a six-point range over the years shown.

In the screener, Gross margin sits in the Profitability group, with quick picks at 30%, 40% and 60%. Screener margins are calculated on the last twelve months, so a single odd quarter can move them.

ROIC of at least 20%, gross margin of at least 40%, operating margin of at least 20% and debt to equity of 1 or less, in the Quality view. You'll need a free account, and the free plan shows the first five results.Open the Wide Moat screen →
Remember

Takeaways

“
Key takeaway
  • Gross margin = (revenue − cost of goods sold) ÷ revenue. It's what's left of each sale after paying for the product itself.
  • What goes into COGS varies by industry and by company. Read the accounting policy before comparing two businesses.
  • A high gross margin that holds steady through years of rising costs is the clearest footprint of pricing power.
  • Cheaper inputs, a richer product mix or a reclassified cost can all lift gross margin with no pricing power behind it.
Sources

Sources for this lesson

  • Warren Buffett, interview with the Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission (May 2010)
  • Robert Novy-Marx, "The other side of value: The gross profitability premium", Journal of Financial Economics (2013)
  • IFRS Foundation, IAS 1 Presentation of Financial Statements (analysis of expenses by nature or by function)
Next lesson · DL 230 · 2 of 5 ◆

Operating leverage

When most of a company's costs are fixed, a small change in sales becomes a big change in profit, in both directions. How to measure it, and why the feature that makes a good year great makes a bad year awful.
Continue
Educational disclaimer · This content is for educational and informational purposes only. It does not constitute investment advice, tax advice, legal advice, or a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Always conduct your own research before making investment decisions.