ROE, ROA, ROIC and ROCE compared
Four ratios, one question: how much does a business earn on the money it uses? They disagree because each defines profit and capital its own way. Here's one company run through all four.
Four ways to divide profit by capital
ROIC's denominator can be built from either side of the balance sheet. The financing approach adds up what lenders and shareholders have put in (debt plus equity) and takes out cash the business doesn't need. The operating approach adds up what the operations use: working capital, fixed assets and acquired intangibles. Done carefully, the two meet. Our ROIC lesson goes through the adjustments.
ROA has a mismatch worth knowing about. Its numerator is profit after interest has been paid to lenders, but its denominator includes the assets the lenders paid for. Some analysts add back after-tax interest to fix it. Most data sites don't bother.
One company, four answers
Calloway Instruments (illustrative) makes testing equipment. A few years ago it bought a smaller rival, which left $600 million of goodwill on its balance sheet.
Same company, same year, and the answers run from 8.8% to 15.5%. ROCE is highest here because it's measured before tax. ROA is lowest because it divides by everything Calloway owns, spare cash and goodwill included, and uses profit after interest. ROE sits above ROIC because Calloway's debt costs it less after tax (3.75%) than the business earns.
Each ratio answers a slightly different question. The real mistake is comparing one company's ROCE with another's ROIC, which happens more often than you'd think.
How debt and buybacks inflate ROE
You can raise ROE without making the business one bit better. Take an illustrative company with $1,000 million of operating capital, earning $160 million of EBIT taxed at 25%. Its ROIC is 12% however it's financed. Now let it borrow at 5% and spend the money buying back its own shares.
Net income fell as the debt grew, and ROE still nearly quadrupled. The shareholders simply fund a smaller slice of the business, and they carry more risk for it. If EBIT halves in a bad year, the debt-free version's net income halves too. The version with $800 million of debt sees net income fall by two-thirds, from $90 million to $30 million.
Buybacks do the same thing more quietly. A company that spends years buying its shares above book value shrinks its equity, sometimes below zero, and several well-known US companies report negative equity for exactly this reason. Their ROE is either enormous or meaningless. In his 1979 letter, Buffett said the test of a management was a high return on equity earned without heavy debt or accounting tricks. ROIC, which counts debt as capital, is much harder to flatter this way.
How goodwill drags ROIC down
Acquisitions push the other way. When a company pays more for another than its net assets are worth, the difference goes onto the balance sheet as goodwill and other acquired intangibles, and those count as invested capital.
Both combined figures are right. Leaving goodwill out tells you the two businesses are still excellent to run. Leaving it in tells you what shareholders earn on everything they've spent, and shows that the deal itself returns 5% until Quill's profits grow a lot. You want to see both.
Which one to use
- ROIC for most operating companies. It's the best single measure of how good the business is, and it doesn't care how the business is financed.
- ROCE as a quick pre-tax cousin of ROIC. It's widely used in the UK and Europe, and handy when tax rates differ a lot between the companies you're comparing.
- ROE and ROA for banks and insurers, where borrowed money is the raw material and invested capital has no clean meaning. A bank's ROE depends heavily on how thinly capitalised it is, so read the two together.
- ROE for everyone else, but only next to the debt figures. A high ROE with an ordinary ROIC is a sign that leverage is doing the work.
Same name, different numbers
Data providers don't agree on the details. Average capital or year-end? The statutory tax rate or the one the company actually paid? How much cash counts as excess, and are leases debt? Two websites can show ROIC for the same company several points apart, and both can be following a defensible formula.
Dividend Line is no exception. The screener's ROIC takes EBIT for the last twelve months, applies a flat 21% tax rate, and divides by total debt plus equity from the latest balance sheet. It doesn't deduct cash and it keeps goodwill in, so a cash-rich company or a serial acquirer will show a lower ROIC there than in a calculation like Calloway's. The Business & Competitors tab takes its ROIC figures from our data provider where it can, so the two pages won't always match.
Returns on Dividend Line
The Chartroom tab has a ROIC & ROE chart beside the Margins chart, with a dashed line at 15% marked as a hurdle. Its reading line counts how many of the periods shown had ROIC of 15% or more. When the two lines sit far apart, check the debt.
In the screener, ROIC, ROE and ROA are in the Profitability group, and the Quality view puts ROIC next to gross margin, operating margin, FCF margin, debt to equity and interest coverage. Combining a minimum ROE with a maximum debt to equity is a simple way to keep out companies whose ROE comes mostly from borrowing.
Takeaways
Sources for this lesson
- Aswath Damodaran, "Return on Capital (ROC), Return on Invested Capital (ROIC) and Return on Equity (ROE): Measurement and Implications", NYU Stern working paper (2007)
- Michael Mauboussin and Dan Callahan, "Calculating Return on Invested Capital", Credit Suisse (2014)
- Tim Koller, Marc Goedhart and David Wessels, Valuation (7th edition, 2020), chapters on reorganising the financial statements and analysing performance
- Warren Buffett, Berkshire Hathaway letter to shareholders (1979)