DL 364 · Joel Greenblatt's Magic Formula · Lesson 3 of 5

Why most people can't stick with it

The formula's real enemy is the person running it. Here's what happened when investors were allowed to pick from the list themselves, and how to protect yourself from you.

Level:Intermediate
◆
Read time:3 min
◆
Course:DL 364
A natural experiment

Same list, two kinds of account

After the book came out, Greenblatt's firm offered two ways to follow the formula. In one kind of account, the rules ran automatically. In the other, clients got the list of top-ranked stocks and chose for themselves which ones to buy and when.

Greenblatt has described what happened over the first two years, from May 2009 to April 2011. The automatic accounts returned about 84% in total. The S&P 500 returned about 63%. The do-it-yourself accounts returned about 59%, trailing the market with the very same list of stocks in front of them.

May 2009 – April 2011 (as Greenblatt reported it)Cumulative return
Accounts that followed the rules automatically≈ 84.1%
S&P 500≈ 62.7%
Self-managed accounts using the same list≈ 59.4%
Diagnosis

What the do-it-yourselfers did

Two habits did the damage. People skipped the names that looked frightening (the company with a scary headline, the retailer everyone was writing off), and those were often the ones that went on to do best. And they stopped buying after the strategy had a bad stretch, then piled back in after it had recovered, which is exactly backwards.

Both mistakes feel sensible in the moment. That's the trouble. The formula only works if you buy what it tells you to buy, especially when you'd rather not.

What to expect

How long can it lag?

Greenblatt is upfront about this in the book. In his tests the formula trailed the market in roughly one year out of four, and there were stretches where it lagged for two or three years in a row. Over any single month, it underperformed a large share of the time.

Write that down before you start. When it happens, and it will, you'll want proof that you knew it was coming.

Guardrails

Rules that protect you from yourself

  1. Decide your number of holdings before you look at the list. Greenblatt suggests 20 to 30.
  2. Set dates. Buy two or three positions a month over your first year, then replace each one after about a year. Put the dates in a calendar.
  3. No vetoes. If you allow yourself to skip names, you'll skip the wrong ones. If you really can't own a company (a business you find unethical, say), replace it with the next name down, never with a favourite.
  4. Commit to at least three to five years. Anything shorter is a bet on a coin toss.
  5. Check the portfolio quarterly, not daily. Daily prices make dry spells feel twice as long.
A test for yourself
Imagine the portfolio is down 15% while the market is up 10% after eighteen months. If your honest answer is that you'd sell, a mechanical strategy isn't for you, and that's a perfectly good thing to find out before you put money in.
Remember

Takeaways

“
Key takeaway
  • With the same list of stocks, investors who picked for themselves trailed the market while the automatic accounts beat it.
  • The costly habits were skipping scary-looking names and stopping after bad stretches.
  • Expect the formula to lag in about one year out of four, sometimes for two or three years running.
  • Fix the rules, the number of holdings and the calendar before you start. Then don't edit.
Sources

Sources for this lesson

  • Joel Greenblatt, The Little Book That Still Beats the Market (2010)
  • Joel Greenblatt, public talks on the Formula Investing accounts (2011–2012)
Next lesson · DL 364 · 4 of 5 ◆

Special situations: spin-offs and forced sellers

Before the formula, Greenblatt made his name on events that push investors to sell for reasons unrelated to value. Spin-offs are the clearest example.
Continue
Educational disclaimer · This content is for educational and informational purposes only. It does not constitute investment advice, tax advice, legal advice, or a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Always conduct your own research before making investment decisions.