Why the formula works
Buying good businesses at low prices sounds too simple to beat professionals. The reason it does has more to do with people than with arithmetic.
Prices swing more than businesses do
A company's value doesn't change much from one month to the next. Its share price can move 50% in a year. Greenblatt borrows Graham's explanation: the market is an emotional business partner who offers you a price every day, sometimes euphoric, sometimes in despair.
The formula is a way to only do business with that partner on his bad days. A company earning a high return on capital that also trades at a high earnings yield is, almost by definition, one the market currently dislikes. It missed a quarter, perhaps, or it's small and nobody covers it.
Most of the time, those worries are either temporary or already more than priced in. When the mood lifts, the price moves back toward value. You don't need to know when. You only need to own enough of these companies for long enough.
What the backtests showed
In the book, Greenblatt tested the formula on US stocks from 1988 to 2004, buying the top-ranked companies and rebalancing once a year. Among the largest 3,500 companies, he reported a return of about 30.8% a year against roughly 12.4% for the S&P 500. Limiting it to the largest 1,000 companies, the edge was smaller but still large.
Independent researchers have since rerun the idea with different data. Wesley Gray and Tobias Carlisle, in Quantitative Value (2012), found that it beat the market in their tests too, though they argued the cheapness half (EBIT over enterprise value) did most of the work.
If it's public, why hasn't it been arbitraged away?
This is the question everyone asks, and Greenblatt's answer is the most useful thing in the book. The formula keeps working because it doesn't work all the time.
There are long stretches when it trails the market. Professional managers who lag their benchmark for two years tend to lose clients, so most of them can't afford to follow a strategy like this, however good its long-run record. Individual investors lose patience even faster. The discomfort is the price of the return.
The 2010s were tough on value
Cheap stocks as a group had a long, painful run from roughly 2010 to 2020, while expensive growth companies did very well. Formula-style strategies weren't spared. Someone who started in 2012 could easily have spent years wondering if the whole idea had stopped working.
Nobody can promise the gap closes on a timetable. What we can say is that the logic, owning good businesses when they're out of favour, hasn't changed, and that the formula's quality half (high return on capital) protected it from the worst of the cheap-for-a-reason companies.
Takeaways
Sources for this lesson
- Joel Greenblatt, The Little Book That Beats the Market (2005), chapters 9–11 and appendix
- Wesley Gray and Tobias Carlisle, Quantitative Value (2012)