Special situations: spin-offs and forced sellers
Before the formula, Greenblatt made his name on events that push investors to sell for reasons unrelated to value. Spin-offs are the clearest example.
You Can Be a Stock Market Genius
Greenblatt's first book, published in 1997, has a ridiculous title and very serious content. It's about corporate events where the usual buyers and sellers behave in predictable, slightly irrational ways: spin-offs, restructurings, merger securities, rights offerings, companies coming out of bankruptcy.
The common thread is a seller who has to sell, or a buyer who isn't allowed to buy. When that happens, price and value come apart for reasons that have nothing to do with the business. Most of Gotham's early returns came from situations like these, not from the formula.
Why spin-offs are often mispriced
In a spin-off, a company separates one of its divisions and hands shares in the new company to its existing shareholders. Those shareholders never asked for the new stock. Many of them don't want it.
- An index fund that owned the parent may be forced to sell the spin-off because it's too small or sits in the wrong index.
- A fund that owns the parent for its dividend may sell a spin-off that pays none.
- Analysts rarely cover the new company at first, so few people have done the work.
All that selling lands in the first weeks and months, often at prices that have little to do with what the business is worth. Meanwhile the managers of the new company usually get a large part of their pay in its shares, so they have every reason to make it work.
Greenblatt cites a Penn State study of spin-offs from 1965 to 1988 which found that they beat their peers and the market by roughly 10% a year over their first three years. Later studies found smaller but still positive effects.
What to look for in a spin-off
- Read the Form 10 (the spin-off's registration document). It's where the new company describes itself before anyone has an opinion about it.
- Check insider incentives. How much stock will management hold, and how is their pay set?
- Look at who will be forced to sell: size, index membership, dividend policy.
- Check the debt. Sometimes the parent loads the spin-off with borrowings on the way out. That's a warning sign, or occasionally an opportunity if the market overreacts.
- Be patient. The best prices often come one to three months after the split, once the forced selling is done.
Other situations in the book
Takeaways
Sources for this lesson
- Joel Greenblatt, You Can Be a Stock Market Genius (1997)
- Patrick Cusatis, James Miles and J. Randall Woolridge, "Restructuring through spinoffs", Journal of Financial Economics (1993)