The defensive investor's seven tests
Graham wrote a checklist for people who want a sound company at a fair price without much work. Here are all seven tests, one company run through them, and the reason most of today's favourites fail.
Defensive or enterprising?
Graham split his readers in two. The defensive investor wants safety and doesn't want to spend much time getting it. The enterprising investor is ready to put in real hours for a better result. He thought most people belonged in the first group and should be honest with themselves about it.
For the defensive investor, chapter 14 of the 1973 edition sets out seven tests a company should pass before it's bought. None of them needs a forecast. Each looks at what has already happened, on the balance sheet or over ten or twenty years of results.
The seven tests
Utilities had their own rules for the first two tests: at least $50 million of total assets, and debt no more than twice the book value of equity.
The size figures are in early-1970s dollars. US consumer prices have gone up roughly eightfold since, so $100 million of sales then is something like $800 million now.
Marlow Industrial Supply, test by test
Marlow (illustrative) distributes bearings, seals and hand tools to factories. Its earnings per share were $2.10, $2.30 and $2.20 at the start of the decade and $3.10, $3.30 and $3.20 over the last three years. The shares trade at $42 and book value is $27 a share.
Marlow passes all seven, but only through the escape clause in test 7. Notice what the averages do in test 5: one unusually good or bad year at either end can't decide the result. Graham asked for them for exactly that reason.
Why great modern companies fail
Now take an invented software company, Ferro Systems. It has grown sales every year for a decade, earns 40% on its capital and has never lost money. It fails four of the seven tests.
- Financial condition: its current ratio is about 1.1, because customers pay a year in advance and that money sits in current liabilities as deferred revenue.
- Dividend record: it started paying six years ago, and it returns most of its cash through buybacks.
- Moderate P/E: it trades at 28 times earnings.
- Price to assets: its P/B is 11, so P/E × P/B comes to about 308.
Some of that is Graham being right. Twenty-eight times earnings is a high price, and high prices leave little margin. A good part of it is accounting, though. A software company's most valuable assets are its code and its customer relationships, and nearly all the money spent building them went through the income statement as an expense. Book value never saw it.
Buybacks shrink book value further. Every dollar spent buying shares at many times book comes straight out of equity, and a few large US companies now report negative book value for that reason alone. Buybacks were rare in Graham's day, too; the SEC only gave companies a clear safe harbour for them in 1982. His dividend test can't see them at all.
The tests still do a fair job on steady, asset-heavy businesses such as industrial distributors and food producers. What they can't do is judge a company whose value sits off the balance sheet. When one fails, ask which kind of failure it is: a high price, or an accounting gap.
Running the tests here
The Valuation tab on every company page has a section on Graham and Greenblatt that scores the seven tests and shows how many pass. It's a simplified version, and it helps to know where it differs from the book.
- Size uses a market value above $2 billion instead of sales.
- Financial condition checks the current ratio only, without the debt-against-net-current-assets half.
- Earnings growth compares the latest year's EPS with the year about ten years earlier, without three-year averages.
- P/E and P/B use trailing twelve-month earnings, and test 7 uses the P/E × P/B form.
- The dividend record counts consecutive years of payments in the history we hold, and adds a + when the record runs longer than our data.
You can also screen for companies that pass most of the tests at once. There's no single Graham preset, but five filters get close: market value of at least $2 billion, a current ratio of at least 2, a dividend streak of 20 years or more, a P/E between 0 and 15, and a P/B of 1.5 or less.
For test 2 on its own, the Fortress List ranks companies by whether their balance sheets could carry them through three bad years, which is close to what Graham wanted from a strong financial condition.
Takeaways
Sources for this lesson
- Benjamin Graham, The Intelligent Investor (1973), chapter 14, Stock Selection for the Defensive Investor
- US Securities and Exchange Commission, Rule 10b-18 (adopted 1982)