Net-nets and the enterprising investor
Graham's favourite bargain was a company selling for less than its cash, receivables and inventory after paying every debt. How to calculate one, why a basket of them worked, and why they're so hard to find now.
More work, wider margins
The enterprising investor does more homework and looks in less comfortable places: smaller companies, unpopular industries, firms with a poor recent record. In return Graham expected bigger margins of safety than the defensive tests give.
Chapter 15 gives this investor a looser checklist. Roughly, a current ratio of at least 1.5, debt no more than 110% of net current assets, no losses in the last five years, some current dividend, earnings higher than a few years earlier, and a price below 120% of net tangible assets. Then Graham went further, to the purest bargain he knew.
Net current asset value
Current assets are the things that turn into cash within a year: cash itself, money customers owe (receivables) and inventory. Take away every liability the company has and what's left is a rough floor for what shareholders own. Factories, land, brands and patents count for nothing.
A net-net is a stock whose market value is below that floor. You're buying the working capital at a discount and getting the rest of the business thrown in. Graham wasn't satisfied with any discount. He wanted a price of two-thirds of NCAV or less, so that a margin of safety sat on top of an already harsh measure.
Dunmore Textiles
At $5.50 the whole company is valued at $55 million. Its plant and equipment, carried at $60 million on the balance sheet, come along at no charge.
Now the sober check. NCAV isn't what you'd get in a sale. Some customers will never pay, and inventory sold in a hurry fetches far less than it cost. Apply rough haircuts and the floor drops a long way.
That's below the $5.50 price. Nobody needs the company wound up for a net-net to pay off. The case rests on the business no longer shrinking, or on management or an acquirer doing something to close the gap. If Dunmore loses $8 million a year, its NCAV drops by 80 cents a share every year, and in a little over four years it's below what you paid.
A basket of unloved companies
Taken one at a time, net-nets are mostly unappealing. Many lose money. Plenty are run by managers nobody admires, in industries nobody wants. Graham knew this, and he bought them in groups, so the occasional disaster was outweighed by the many that drifted back toward NCAV or got taken over.
It held up in later tests. Henry Oppenheimer studied US net-nets from 1970 to 1983 and found that portfolios of them beat the market indexes by a wide margin.
Where did all the net-nets go?
In 1932 Graham wrote a series of Forbes articles asking whether American business was worth more dead than alive, because so many companies traded below their net current assets. Today they're scarce outside crashes, and almost none are large companies. When the lists do grow long, it's usually for a few months after a market collapse.
The ones that are left tend to come with a catch.
- Size. Most are micro caps. Spreads are wide, and a modest order can move the price.
- Cash you can't reach. The money may sit under a controlling family, or in a country that makes it hard to pay out.
- Cash that isn't there. Around 2010 and 2011 a wave of US-listed companies with operations in China turned out to have far less cash than their accounts showed.
- A business that burns it. A company losing money every year eats its own NCAV, as Dunmore shows.
Hunters still find them, often among small companies in Japan, where many firms have held large cash piles for years. The rules haven't changed. Buy many, keep each position small, and read the balance sheet for anything that would stop the cash reaching shareholders.
Hunting with the screener
The screener has no NCAV field, so you'll finish the job by hand. Its Deep Value preset is the closest thing to Graham's enterprising style: a P/E of 12 or less, P/B and P/S of 1.5 or less, debt to equity no higher than 0.8 and a current ratio of at least 1.5.
Use the latest balance sheet in the Financials tab and include every liability, leases and pension obligations too. Our financial statements lesson shows where each line sits.
Takeaways
Sources for this lesson
- Benjamin Graham, The Intelligent Investor (1973), chapter 15, Stock Selection for the Enterprising Investor, and postscript
- Benjamin Graham, "Is American Business Worth More Dead Than Alive?", Forbes (1932)
- Henry Oppenheimer, "Ben Graham's Net Current Asset Values: A Performance Update", Financial Analysts Journal (1986)