Mr. Market
Graham's best-known idea is a story about a moody business partner. It explains why share prices swing so much more than businesses do, and what you're allowed to do about it.
The man Buffett learned from
Benjamin Graham was born in London in 1894 and grew up in New York. He spent his working life on Wall Street and, for many years, teaching at Columbia Business School. Two of his books are still in print. Security Analysis (1934, written with David Dodd) is the professional's manual. The Intelligent Investor (1949) is the version for everyone else, and this course follows its last revision by Graham, from 1973.
He learned caution the hard way. The partnership he ran lost roughly 70% between 1929 and 1932, and a lot of what he wrote afterwards reads like a set of rules for never going through that again.
Warren Buffett read The Intelligent Investor at 19. He later worked for Graham's firm, Graham-Newman, from 1954 until it closed in 1956. Some of Graham's ideas have aged badly since, and this course says where. The first one hasn't aged at all.
A partner who quotes you a price every day
Picture a small private business, a hardware wholesaler say, that you own together with a partner. Every morning he knocks on your door and names a price. He'll buy your share at that price, or sell you more of his. You can accept, or you can shut the door. He'll be back tomorrow either way, and he never takes offence.
“One of your partners, named Mr. Market, is very obliging indeed.”
The catch is his mood. Some days he's so cheerful that his price is far above anything the business could be worth. On others he's sure the end is near and will hand you his share for a fraction of its value. The business hasn't changed in between. Same customers, same profits.
That's Graham's picture of the stock market. Every listed company comes with its own Mr. Market, who now shouts a new quote several times a second. The quote is an offer, and you're free to say no.
Three years, three moods, one business
Halden Supply is an invented wholesaler with very steady results. It earns $2.50 a share every year and pays a $1.20 dividend. After studying it, you think it's worth something like $35 a share, about 14 times earnings. Here's what Mr. Market offers over three years.
Earnings and the dividend were identical in all three years. Only the price moved, and between year two and year three it fell by about 60%.
Graham's advice for each year is plain. In year one there's nothing to do, since the price is close to your estimate. In year two you could sell him some shares, or at least decline to buy. In year three he's offering a dollar of value for 60 cents. That's the day to buy, provided you have the cash and your numbers still hold.
Take his prices, ignore his opinions
Graham's rule was to let Mr. Market serve you and never let him tell you what your business is worth. Use his low quotes to buy and his high ones to sell. The rest of the time, you can forget he exists.
That only works if you have your own estimate of value. Without one, you've nothing to compare his price with, and you'll end up borrowing his mood. So the rest of this course is about measuring value from earnings and assets.
The mood swings are real, and they're big. The S&P 500 fell about 34% in five weeks between February and March 2020, then made a new high that August. For most companies in the index, the long-run business looked much the same at the end of those six months as at the start. The price did all the travelling.
Sometimes Mr. Market knows something
The parable has a weak spot. Mr. Market is moody, but he isn't always wrong. If a retailer's shares fall 40% because it's losing customers to a cheaper rival, the drop is information. Treating every fall as a mood swing is how people keep buying a shrinking business all the way down.
Two habits help. Write down why you think the business is worth what you think, before the price moves, so you can check later whether the reason still holds. And look at the price less often. Graham's partner knocked once a day. Your phone can knock every few seconds, and each knock is an invitation to react.
Takeaways
Sources for this lesson
- Benjamin Graham, The Intelligent Investor (1973), chapter 8, "The Investor and Market Fluctuations"
- Warren Buffett, Berkshire Hathaway letter to shareholders (1987)