DL 360 · Benjamin Graham · Lesson 2 of 5

The margin of safety

Graham called it the central concept of investment. In plain terms it's a gap between what you pay and what you think you're getting, wide enough to survive your own mistakes.

Level:Intermediate
◆
Read time:5 min
◆
Course:DL 360
The idea

Room for being wrong

Engineers who rate a lift for 1,000 kg don't expect anyone to load it with 990. They build in slack, because their calculations won't be perfect and neither will the people using the lift. Graham asked investors to do the same thing with price.

Any estimate of what a business is worth rests on guesses about the future, and some of those guesses will be wrong. Pay well below your estimate and they can be off by a fair amount while you still come out fine. Pay close to it and you need to be right.

“The function of the margin of safety is, in essence, that of rendering unnecessary an accurate estimate of the future.”
Benjamin Graham, The Intelligent Investor (1973), ch. 20

He gave the idea the last chapter of the book, titled "Margin of Safety" as the Central Concept of Investment. If you only read one chapter of The Intelligent Investor, read that one.

Margin of safety
(Estimated value − Price) ÷ Estimated value
A $50 estimate and a $33 price give a margin of 34%.
Worked example

The same mistake at two prices

Brenton Foods (illustrative) is a steady packaged-food maker. Your careful estimate of its value is $50 a share. It turns out you were too optimistic by a quarter, and the business is really worth $37.50. Here's how that one error lands at two purchase prices.

Worked example
Bought at $33, a 34% margin
Your estimate$50.00
Real value$37.50
Price paid$33.00
Result once the price reaches real value37.50 ÷ 33 − 1 = +13.6%
Worked example
Bought at $48, a 4% margin
Your estimate$50.00
Real value$37.50
Price paid$48.00
Result once the price reaches real value37.50 ÷ 48 − 1 = −21.9%

Same company, same 25% error. The price alone turned a loss of more than a fifth into a gain. That's the margin of safety doing its job.

Where it comes from

Where Graham looked for it

Source of the marginWhat it looks likeGraham's typical test
Price below valueYou pay well under a conservative estimate of what the business is worthNet-nets bought at two-thirds of net current assets (lesson 4)
Earnings well above bond yieldsThe stock earns far more on your price than a top-grade bond paysEarnings yield comfortably above the high-grade bond yield
A strong balance sheetLittle debt and plenty of current assets, so a bad year can't sink the companyCurrent ratio of 2 or more, long-term debt below working capital (lesson 3)

The middle row needs a word. In chapter 20 Graham argued that when a stock's earnings yield sits well above what high-grade bonds pay, the difference piles up in your favour year after year. Here's the reasoning with our own round numbers.

Worked example
Earnings yield against bonds (illustrative)
Share price$30
Earnings per share$3.00
Earnings yield3.00 ÷ 30 = 10%
High-grade bond yield5%
Excess per year5 points
Over ten years, before any compoundingabout 50% of the price paid

That extra 50 cents per dollar, earned whether it's paid out or reinvested, is a cushion that can absorb a bad patch. It only works if the earnings are real and fairly stable, which is why Graham wanted a long record before he trusted them.

Odds

Why one margin isn't enough

Graham was clear that a margin of safety improves the odds without guaranteeing any single result. A company bought at a big discount can still go bust. What the margin offers is that, across many such purchases, the gains should outweigh the losses.

So he paired it with diversification. For his defensive investor he suggested owning at least ten companies and no more than about thirty. A margin of safety on one stock is a bet. On twenty-five, it starts to look like arithmetic.

Where it breaks

When the value comes down to meet the price

A margin is measured against a value, and values move. In a shrinking business the value can fall toward your purchase price faster than the price climbs toward the value. Investors call this a value trap.

Worked example
A margin that melts (illustrative)
Value at purchase$50.00
Price paid$33.00 (a 34% margin)
Value after falling 10% a year for four years50 × 0.9⁴ ≈ $32.80
Margin leftNone

The arithmetic at the start was fine. The $50 was a snapshot of a business heading down.

Growth is the other weak point. Graham was wary of any margin that depended on forecasts, so his tests lean on past earnings and on assets. Buffett, his best-known student, later argued (with a push from Charlie Munger) that a wonderful business at a fair price could carry its margin inside its future growth. Both views can be right, for different companies. Lesson 5 comes back to this.

◆Analyst note
On Dividend Line, the Valuation tab shows how far the price sits from a blended fair value, and the screener has a Margin of safety filter measured against our Buffett-lens value. Both are estimates. Treat them as someone else's homework to check, and keep a margin of your own on top.
Remember

Takeaways

“
Key takeaway
  • Margin of safety = (estimated value − price) ÷ estimated value. It's room for your estimate to be wrong.
  • The same 25% mistake became a 13.6% gain at a $33 price and a 21.9% loss at $48.
  • Graham found margins in low prices against value, in earnings yields well above bond yields, and in strong balance sheets.
  • A margin improves the odds on a group of stocks. Graham's defensive investor held ten to about thirty.
  • In a shrinking business the value can fall to meet your price. Check the trend as well as the gap.
Sources

Sources for this lesson

Next lesson · DL 360 · 3 of 5 ◆

The defensive investor's seven tests

Graham wrote a checklist for people who want a sound company at a fair price without much work. Here are all seven tests, one company run through them, and the reason most of today's favourites fail.
Continue
Educational disclaimer · This content is for educational and informational purposes only. It does not constitute investment advice, tax advice, legal advice, or a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Always conduct your own research before making investment decisions.