Net debt and leverage ratios
Two numbers tell you most of what you need about a company's borrowing: how much it owes after its cash, and how that compares with what the business earns. A third number, debt to equity, is more famous and less reliable.
What counts as debt
Ask a company what it owes and you'll get a long list: suppliers waiting to be paid, wages, tax, pension promises. Most of that is the ordinary friction of running a business. When analysts say debt, they mean money that was borrowed, carries interest and has to be repaid on a fixed date. Bonds and bank loans count, and so does commercial paper (very short IOUs that large companies roll over every few weeks).
Leases are the grey area. A retailer renting 900 shops has promised years of rent as firmly as a bond promises its coupons, and since 2019 both IFRS 16 and the US rule, ASC 842, have put most leases on the balance sheet. Many analysts now add them to debt. Whichever way you go, say so and do the same for every company you compare. In this course, debt includes leases unless we say otherwise.
Net debt
The cash comes off because a company could repay part of its debt tomorrow with money it already holds. Not every dollar is spare, though. A retailer needs cash in the tills, and some cash sits in countries that tax or restrict it on the way out. Count a big pile as available only when the business plainly doesn't need it to operate.
Net debt ÷ EBITDA
A billion dollars of net debt would crush a company earning $50 million a year and barely register at one earning $5 billion. So net debt is divided by EBITDA (operating profit with depreciation and amortisation added back), a rough measure of the cash the operations produce before interest and tax.
As a rough guide, below 1× is light for most industrial and consumer businesses. Above 3× the debt needs a good reason to be there. Utilities and property companies run higher because their income is steadier, often set by regulators or long leases.
Debt ÷ equity, and why book equity can mislead
Buybacks are where the ratio goes wrong. Each one takes cash out and cuts equity by the same amount. Keep going, partly with borrowed money, and equity drops below zero while profits keep rising. McDonald's and AutoZone have both reported negative shareholders' equity for years, and few people would call either business fragile. Their debt to equity is a negative number that means nothing. Acquisitions push the other way, since the goodwill they create props up equity and flatters the ratio.
Same EBITDA, opposite stories
Two illustrative companies, each with $400 million of EBITDA.
Alder looks tame on debt to equity, yet it borrows far more per dollar of earnings, and its leases alone move it from 2.75× to 3.5×. Pemberton owes less, though a careless screen would read its negative debt to equity as brilliant or broken.
EBITDA isn't cash
The years-to-repay reading is generous, because EBITDA ignores capital spending, tax and the interest itself. Say Alder spends $120 million a year on equipment, $50 million on tax and $70 million on interest. That leaves $160 million, so its 3.5× is closer to nine years of free cash (1,400 ÷ 160 = 8.75) before a cent goes to dividends.
Watch the EBITDA itself, too. At the top of a cycle it flatters everyone, and the adjusted EBITDA many companies publish leaves out costs management would rather you ignored. Leases add a wrinkle: under IFRS 16 rent moves out of operating costs, which lifts EBITDA, while under US rules most of it stays in. Compare like with like.
The Fortress Score, wall by wall
Every company page has a Fortress tab. It asks whether the company could ride out three bad years on its own money, without going to a bank or the bond market, and answers with a score out of 100 built from six walls.
The leverage wall gives full marks at 1× or less (or with more cash than debt) and nothing at 7×. Above 2× net debt to EBITDA, a company can't be graded Fortress however well it covers its interest; utilities and REITs get more room. The grades run from Fortress (85 and up) through Solid, Stretched and Fragile down to Distress (under 30).
The score doesn't use debt to equity at all, and the tab's Myth & reality section says so when buybacks have pushed equity below zero. McDonald's Fortress tab is a good first one to read.
Takeaways
Sources for this lesson
- Martin Fridson and Fernando Alvarez, Financial Statement Analysis: A Practitioner's Guide (4th edition, 2011)
- IASB, IFRS 16 Leases (2016), and FASB, ASC 842 Leases (2016)