Liquidity: cash, credit lines, covenants
A company can be worth far more than it owes and still miss a payment due on Thursday. Liquidity is about the next twelve months: the cash in hand and the bank lines behind it, with whatever conditions the lenders attached.
Solvent, and still out of cash
Solvency is the long view: over the years, can the business earn enough to pay everything it owes? Liquidity is the short view. Can it pay the bills that land this month or this quarter?
Plenty of companies that failed would have recovered given time. The money ran out first, often because a big loan fell due in a month when lenders were scared.
Current ratio and quick ratio
The quick ratio leaves out inventory because stock is the slowest and least certain thing to turn into cash. In a bad season it sells at a discount, if it sells at all.
The current ratio looks fine. The quick ratio shows that two-thirds of Garnet's current assets are sofas and lamps still in the warehouse.
A low current ratio isn't always a warning. Supermarkets and fast-food chains collect cash at the till and pay their suppliers weeks later, so their current liabilities run ahead of current assets as a matter of course. For them a ratio below 1 is simply how the business works.
Cash runway
Young drug developers and other loss-makers live by this number. Linden Therapeutics (illustrative) has $360 million and burns $30 million a month: 12 months. That sounds like plenty, but raising money takes months, and a company with six left negotiates from weakness. Expect new shares at a low price well before the cash runs out.
Undrawn credit lines
Most large companies have a revolving credit facility, usually called a revolver. A group of banks commits to lend up to a set amount for several years, and the company pays a small fee on the part it hasn't used. The annual report gives the size and the unused amount, usually in the debt note or in the liquidity section of management's discussion.
In March 2020 many large companies drew down their lines in full within days, to hold cash while markets froze. That's what the lines are for. Drawing one doesn't change net debt, by the way. Cash and debt both rise by the same amount, and only the interest bill goes up.
Treat an undrawn line as real money only with two checks. The line has its own expiry date, and banks don't have to renew it. And a company that has broken its covenants usually can't draw at all, which is exactly when it would want to.
Covenants
Covenants are conditions written into a loan. The two you'll meet most are a maximum leverage (net debt no higher than, say, 3.5× EBITDA) and a minimum interest cover (EBITDA at least 3× interest, for example).
Bank loans usually carry maintenance covenants, tested every quarter whatever the company does. Many high-yield bonds use incurrence covenants instead, which only bite when the company takes an action such as borrowing more or paying a dividend.
Breaking a maintenance covenant is technically a default, and the lenders can demand their money back at once. In practice they usually grant a waiver or rewrite the terms. That costs a fee and a higher interest rate, and often a ban on dividends and buybacks until things improve. Cross-default clauses in other loans can turn one breach into several.
The leverage covenant bites first, after a 20% fall in EBITDA. For a homeware retailer, one poor Christmas could do that.
A snapshot taken on a good day
A balance sheet is a photo of one day, and companies choose the day. A toy retailer's year end comes after Christmas, when the stock has sold and the cash is in, so its liquidity looks better than it would in October. Check the same ratio in the quarterly reports.
Covenant definitions are written by the borrower's lawyers as much as the bank's. The EBITDA in a loan agreement is often adjusted, with add-backs your own number won't have, so a company can be inside its covenants while looking outside them on your figures. The loan agreement, filed as an exhibit to the annual report, has the exact wording.
Wall IV, and what it leaves out
The liquidity wall is worth 10 points. It sets cash on the balance sheet against the debt due within a year plus a year of interest, and gives full marks when cash alone covers all of it. Undrawn credit lines don't count. The wall uses cash only, which matches the caution above: a line can vanish on the day it's needed.
Myth & reality on the Fortress tab picks up two of this lesson's traps. A current ratio below 1 is explained when the company holds little inventory. And commercial paper that a company books as long-term debt, because a bank line stands behind it, is moved into year one so it can't hide.
In the screener, the balance sheet filters include current ratio and quick ratio, both read from the latest balance sheet, usually the quarterly one.
Takeaways
Sources for this lesson
- Martin Fridson and Fernando Alvarez, Financial Statement Analysis: A Practitioner's Guide (4th edition, 2011)
- Edward I. Altman, Edith Hotchkiss and Wei Wang, Corporate Financial Distress, Restructuring, and Bankruptcy (4th edition, 2019)