Yield vs yield trap
A high yield is a price, and the market sets it for a reason. Here's how to tell an honest bargain from a dividend that's about to be cut.
What a yield is really telling you
The formula has two moving parts, and only one of them is the dividend. A yield can rise because the company paid more. Much more often, it rises because the share price fell.
That's why a 9% yield should make you curious before it makes you excited. The market is full of people who can divide one number by another. If they're willing to accept 9% from a company while the bond market pays 4%, they're telling you they don't believe the 9% will last.
Sometimes they're wrong, and that's where the good dividend buys come from. Your job is to work out which case you're looking at.
Trailing, forward and special
Check which dividend sits on top of the fraction. A trailing yield uses what was paid over the last twelve months. A forward yield uses the current rate, annualised. If a company has just cut, the trailing yield still shows the old, larger payments for up to a year and looks far more generous than reality.
Special dividends do the same trick. A one-off payment from an asset sale can double the trailing yield for twelve months. It won't happen again, so take it out before you compare.
Five cuts that looked obvious afterwards
In almost every case, the signs were visible a year or more in advance: payments that free cash flow didn't cover, debt rising to fund them, and a business shrinking or under pressure. The yield itself was the loudest sign of all.
Seven signs of a yield trap
- The dividend is larger than free cash flow, year after year. (Lesson 2 shows how to check.)
- Net debt keeps rising while the dividend stays flat. Someone is borrowing to pay you.
- Revenue or operating profit has been falling for several years.
- The yield is far above the company's own history and well above its peers.
- Management has stopped raising the dividend after a long run of increases. A freeze often comes before a cut.
- The company talks about "strategic alternatives", a spin-off or a large restructuring.
- Analysts and management describe the dividend as "a priority" a little too often.
One sign on its own proves nothing. Three or four together and we'd want a very good reason to buy.
When a high yield is a real bargain
Not every high yield ends badly. Good businesses get cheap when their whole sector falls out of favour, when interest rates jump, or when a single bad quarter scares people off. If the dividend is covered by free cash flow, the debt is manageable and the business isn't shrinking, a yield well above its usual range can be the best entry you'll get for years.
The test is boring and that's the point. Ignore the yield for a moment, check coverage and debt, and only then decide whether the price is a gift.
A five-minute check
Most of the warning signs above take a few minutes to check. This is the order we go in on any company page.
- Dividends tab: ten years of dividend per share. Rising steadily, flat, or already trimmed once?
- The yield today against its own range over the last ten years.
- Dividends paid next to free cash flow for each of the last five years. Lesson 2 shows how.
- Net debt over EBITDA, and whether it has been climbing.
- Last, the most recent earnings call or MD&A, for how management talks about the dividend.
The dividend hasn't moved. The price has dropped nearly 40% below the bottom of its usual range. Either the market knows something about the next payment, or it's panicking. The coverage and debt checks tell you which.