Withholding tax across borders
Buy a foreign dividend stock and two governments may want a share of each payment. How withholding works, why one form can save you half the tax at source, and what you keep after your own country's tax.
Tax taken before you see the money
When a company pays a dividend to someone living in another country, its home government usually keeps a slice at source. That's withholding tax. You receive what's left, and then your own country may tax the dividend again.
Tax treaties between countries exist to stop that double hit. They cap the source country's slice (often at 15%) and let your home country give you a credit for what was already taken. The catch is that the cap rarely applies automatically. You, or your broker, have to claim it.
Statutory rates on dividends to foreign investors
Form W-8BEN
If you hold US shares from outside the US, this is the most valuable form you'll ever fill in. It tells the US that you're a resident of a treaty country, which cuts the withholding on dividends from 30% to the treaty rate: 15% for most treaty countries, including the UK and Canada.
Most brokers ask for it when you open an account and handle the rest. It stays valid until the end of the third calendar year after you sign it, so check that yours hasn't quietly expired. Your broker's statements will show 30% being taken if it has.
What you keep from a US dividend
Every country taxes dividends its own way, so take this as an illustration of the mechanics. Imagine an investor whose home country taxes dividends at 25% and, like many countries, gives a credit for foreign tax but only up to the treaty rate: 15% for US dividends.
The extra $150 can in theory be reclaimed from the US tax authority. In practice, almost nobody bothers, so it's simply lost. One form makes a 15-point difference on every US dividend you'll ever receive.
ETFs, REITs and tax-sheltered accounts
- An ETF domiciled in Ireland that holds US shares pays 15% US withholding inside the fund, thanks to the US–Ireland treaty, and Ireland usually takes nothing more on the way out to you. That's one reason many European investors prefer Irish-domiciled funds.
- Dividends from US REITs and some other structures can be treated differently from ordinary dividends. Read your broker's tax summary for the year.
- Some countries' retirement or tax-free accounts can't recover foreign withholding at all. Holding high-yield foreign stocks inside them can cost more than you'd expect.
The broad lesson: before you buy a foreign dividend stock, know what you'll actually keep from each payment. A 5% yield that nets 2.9% after two layers of tax isn't a 5% yield.
Records worth keeping
Your broker's annual tax statement should list, for each foreign dividend, the gross amount, the tax withheld and the country. Keep it. Most tax returns have a section for foreign income, where you declare the gross dividend and the tax already withheld so the credit can be applied.
- Gross dividend and payment date, for each payment.
- Tax withheld at source, by country.
- Any reclaim you file, and when the refund arrives.
- The date your W-8BEN (or equivalent form) expires.
Reclaims from countries like Germany or Switzerland can take a year or more, and on small holdings the fees can eat most of the refund. For a few hundred dollars of dividends a year, it can be cheaper to accept the loss, or to own those companies through a fund instead.
Takeaways
Sources for this lesson
- IRS, Instructions for Form W-8BEN
- OECD, Model Tax Convention on Income and on Capital, Article 10 (Dividends)
- IRS, Publication 515: Withholding of Tax on Nonresident Aliens and Foreign Entities