Payout and free cash flow coverage
Earnings can be dressed up. Cash can't, at least not for long. How to check whether a dividend is really paid for, and how it would hold up in a bad year.
Earnings payout and cash payout
The earnings version is the one you'll see quoted everywhere. It's a fine first look. The trouble is that earnings include non-cash items and accounting choices, while the dividend is paid in cash. A company can show a comfortable 55% earnings payout and still be paying out more cash than it brings in.
That's why we lean on the cash version. If you want the full background on free cash flow itself, our free cash flow lesson covers it.
A comfortable payout that isn't
On earnings, Larchmont looks safe. On cash, it paid out $20 million more than it generated, and the gap came from new borrowing. One year like this is fine. Three in a row is a pattern.
How much payout is too much?
There's no single right number, because businesses differ in how steady their cash is. These are the ranges we use as a first filter, measured on free cash flow over several years.
For REITs the earnings payout is close to useless, because depreciation makes accounting profit look tiny. The REIT lesson explains AFFO, the measure to use instead.
Would it survive a bad year?
Coverage in a normal year is the easy test. The harder question is what happens when things go wrong. We run a simple version on every dividend we care about.
- Take the average free cash flow of the last five years.
- Cut it by 30% (by 50% for a cyclical business).
- Compare the result with the current dividend.
- If the dividend is no longer covered, check whether the balance sheet could carry the gap for two years without net debt passing about three times EBITDA.
A dividend that passes both steps is about as safe as dividends get. One that fails both is a cut waiting for a recession.
Don't forget the buybacks
Many companies return as much cash through share repurchases as through dividends. Add the two together for a total payout ratio. A company paying 50% of free cash flow in dividends and another 70% in buybacks is spending 120% of its cash on shareholders, and something has to give in a downturn.
Buybacks are the part management can switch off quietly. Dividends aren't. That's a good thing for dividend investors, as long as the buybacks are the first thing cut.
Look at five years, not one
A single year's coverage can mislead in either direction. A big capital project can push free cash flow below the dividend for a year or two in a perfectly healthy company. A strong year can hide a business in slow decline. Five years side by side usually settles it.
Year 3 on its own looks alarming. Over five years the dividend took 73% of free cash flow, and the dip had a clear cause that ended. Compare that with a company whose payout creeps up every year with no project to explain it. That second pattern is the one that ends in a cut.