Stock-based compensation and the real FCF
Paying staff in shares costs no cash, so the cash flow statement adds it back and free cash flow ignores it. The owners still pay, through dilution or through the buybacks needed to cancel it.
An expense that skips the cash flow
Since the mid-2000s, companies have had to put the value of share awards to employees through the income statement as an expense: IFRS 2 from 2005, and the US rule now known as ASC 718 from 2006. Net income includes it. The cash flow statement then adds it back, because no cash left the company. Free cash flow, calculated as operating cash flow minus capex, inherits the add-back. So the most popular cash measure in investing treats share-based pay as free.
At a typical industrial company stock-based compensation is a small fraction of revenue and hardly matters. At many software and internet companies it can run to 10% of revenue or more, and eat a large slice of free cash flow.
“If compensation isn't an expense, what is it?”
Shares are a currency
Imagine the company sold new shares to investors and used the cash to pay salaries. Everyone would call the salaries a cost. Handing the shares to employees directly is the same transaction with one step removed. The company gives away something it could have sold, and existing owners end up with a smaller slice.
There are two honest ways to account for it. Subtract stock-based compensation from free cash flow and value the company on today's share count. Or leave free cash flow alone and track the dilution: watch the share count, work in per-share figures, and assume the count keeps growing in any forecast. Doing both counts the cost twice.
Per-share figures do some of the work for you. If free cash flow rises 15% in a year while the diluted share count rises 3%, free cash flow per share is up about 11.7% (1.15 ÷ 1.03). That's the number an owner actually gets.
Selwyn's buyback
Selwyn Software (illustrative) sells accounting software by subscription. Revenue is $3,000 million, there are 500 million shares, and the market values the company at $30,000 million, or $60 a share.
Selwyn's annual report says it returned $400 million to shareholders. The share count fell 0.2%. About 5.7 million new shares went to employees during the year, so most of the buyback simply mopped them up. In cash terms that's what the stock-based pay cost: roughly $340 million spent to stand still.
Gross buybacks, net buybacks
Most companies report gross buybacks, the cash spent. What matters to an owner is the net effect on the share count. A company that spends 3% of its market value on buybacks while issuing 2.5% in new shares to staff is shrinking the count by about half a per cent a year.
The cost of offsetting dilution also depends on the share price. The expense is measured when the awards are granted. If the shares have risen by the time the company buys back the same number, the buyback costs more than the expense showed; if they've fallen, less. For a company whose shares have doubled, the cash cost of standing still can be well above the add-back on the cash flow statement.
One more cash cost hides in financing. When awards vest, many US companies keep back some of the shares and pay the employee's tax in cash on their behalf. That payment goes in the financing section, often labelled something like taxes paid related to net share settlement, so it never touches operating cash flow or free cash flow. Count it with the buybacks.
Rough edges
- Grant-date values lag. After a share price collapse, this year's expense still reflects grants made at higher prices, so subtracting it can overstate the cost for a while. Then the company often hands out many more shares to keep its staff, and the count jumps.
- Adjusted figures. Many companies publish adjusted EBITDA and adjusted earnings that leave stock-based pay out. If you use those numbers, put it back.
- Small amounts. Where stock-based pay is a fraction of a per cent of revenue, as at many utilities, both methods give the same answer. Spend your time elsewhere.
Stock-based pay on Dividend Line
Free cash flow on Dividend Line is operating cash flow minus capital expenditure everywhere on the site, from the company pages to the screener's FCF margin, FCF yield, P/FCF and FCF payout ratio. None of them subtracts stock-based compensation. For a software company, do the Selwyn adjustment yourself. The Financials tab lists stock-based compensation in its Cash Flow section, a few lines above free cash flow, and the diluted share count in its Income section.
The Financial Flows tab draws stock-based pay as its own band in the operating section, so you can see at a glance how much of operating cash flow it accounts for.
Dilution shows up on the Buybacks tab. Its SBC Offset Ratio divides money spent on repurchases by stock-based compensation over the last twelve months. At 3× or more the tab calls the buyback genuinely accretive, from 1.2× to 3× a modest net buyback, and below 1.2× it warns that buybacks barely cancel dilution. Next to it, Buyback / Dilution Yrs counts the years the share count fell against the years it rose. The tab's buyback quality score gives the same offset ratio, measured over all the years it covers, 15% of its weight.
Takeaways
Sources for this lesson
- Warren Buffett, Berkshire Hathaway letter to shareholders (1992)
- IFRS Foundation, IFRS 2 Share-based Payment; FASB, ASC 718 Compensation: Stock Compensation
- FASB, ASU 2016-09, Improvements to Employee Share-Based Payment Accounting (2016), on classifying tax withheld on net share settlement