Maintenance vs growth capex
Free cash flow subtracts every dollar of capital spending, including the part meant to make the business bigger. Splitting capex into what keeps the company standing and what grows it can change how cheap a stock looks, and no statement does the split for you.
Spending to stand still, spending to grow
A bottler that replaces worn-out filling lines is spending to stay where it is. If it builds a second plant to serve a new region, it's spending to grow. Both land on the same line of the cash flow statement, purchases of property, plant and equipment, and both come off when you calculate free cash flow.
For valuing a business the difference matters. Maintenance spending is a cost of staying in business, as unavoidable as wages. Growth spending is a choice. The company could stop, and if the new plant earns a good return you'd want it to carry on.
Buffett drew this line in the appendix to his 1986 letter, where he defined owner earnings. His recipe, paraphrased: reported earnings, plus depreciation, amortisation and other non-cash charges, minus the average yearly capital spending the business needs to hold its competitive position and its unit volume. If it also needs extra working capital to hold that position, that comes off too. He was candid that the capex figure is a guess.
No statement gives you the split
Accounting rules don't ask companies to divide capex between maintenance and growth, and most don't. Some give a rough split on earnings calls or in management's discussion. Pipeline partnerships and REITs report it more often than most, because their payouts are built on it.
Treat a company's own split with care. Every dollar it labels growth makes its free cash flow look more generous, and nobody audits the label. So you estimate it yourself, and there are two common ways. It's worth doing both.
Depreciation as a stand-in
Depreciation spreads the cost of past purchases across their useful lives. In a business that isn't growing, with stable prices, the yearly cost of replacing worn assets should be close to the yearly depreciation charge. That makes depreciation the quickest estimate of maintenance capex.
Use depreciation of property, plant and equipment, not the combined D&A figure. Amortisation of intangibles bought in an acquisition (customer lists, brand names) doesn't call for a cheque to replace them. Whatever keeps them alive, such as marketing, already runs through the income statement.
The weak spot is inflation. A machine bought in 2012 is depreciated at its 2012 price, and replacing it costs more today. For businesses with long-lived assets like rail track or shopping centres, depreciation can understate the true cost of standing still by a wide margin. Where prices fall, as with computer equipment, it can overstate it.
A simple companion check is capex divided by depreciation. A ratio above 1 for years on end usually means the company is expanding. Below 1 for years means it's shrinking, or putting off spending it will have to make later.
Greenwald's method
Bruce Greenwald and his co-authors set out a second approach in Value Investing: From Graham to Buffett and Beyond (2001). Work out how much plant each dollar of extra sales needs, charge that much to growth, and call the rest maintenance.
- For each of the past five years or so, divide property, plant and equipment (PP&E) by sales, and average the results. That's how much plant the business carries per dollar of sales.
- Multiply that average by this year's increase in sales. The answer is growth capex: the plant needed to support the extra sales.
- Subtract growth capex from total capex. What's left is your estimate of maintenance capex.
The two estimates of maintenance, 60 and 70, sit close together, which is reassuring. Had they been 60 and 140 you'd want to know why before trusting either. On a market value of $1,950 million, Hartwell's free cash flow yield is 4.6% as reported and 6.7% on the maintenance basis.
That gap is what Hartwell spends on growth, and the spending only earns its keep if the new capacity makes a decent return. Our lesson on incremental ROIC shows how to check.
When the estimates mislead
- Price rises posing as growth. If Hartwell's sales rose 10% only because it raised prices, it needed no new plant, and all 110 was probably maintenance. Use volume growth where the company reports it.
- Falling sales. When sales shrink, the method gives negative growth capex, which makes no sense. The usual fix is to treat that year's capex as all maintenance.
- Lumpy spending. A refinery shuts for a big overhaul every four or five years. Judge maintenance over a full cycle of those, never from one year.
- Spending that isn't capex. At a software company the assets that wear out are code and people, and keeping them current runs through research costs on the income statement. Capex tells you little there.
- Growth that isn't optional. Where rivals keep adding capacity, the spending a company calls growth may be what it takes to keep its market share. That's maintenance by another name.
Capex on Dividend Line
There's no maintenance capex figure anywhere on the site. Free cash flow on Dividend Line is always operating cash flow minus all capital expenditure, so for a company building new capacity it's the cautious number.
The Chartroom tab's Cash Machine chapter has two charts that help. Operating vs free cash flow puts the two side by side, and the gap between the bars is capex. Its reading line says what share of operating cash capex took in the latest year, and flags it when that was the widest in the years shown. CapEx / revenue tracks capital intensity and compares the latest year with its median over the period. A jump well above the median usually means a building programme, and that's your cue to find out what's being built.
The Financial Flows tab gives capex as a share of revenue on its CapEx tile. For Greenwald's method you'll need PP&E from the balance sheet in the annual report, since the Financials tab lists sales and D&A but not PP&E.
Takeaways
Sources for this lesson
- Bruce Greenwald, Judd Kahn, Paul Sonkin and Michael van Biema, Value Investing: From Graham to Buffett and Beyond (2001), chapter on earnings power value
- Warren Buffett, Berkshire Hathaway letter to shareholders (1986), appendix on owner earnings