FCF conversion and quality of earnings
One ratio sums up most of this course: how much of a company's reported profit turns into free cash. How to read it, why it can mislead in both directions, and what the research says about profit that isn't backed by cash.
FCF conversion
Its close relative, cash conversion (operating cash flow ÷ net income), skips capex, so it isolates the accrual and working capital effects from lesson 1. Some companies report free cash flow against EBITDA instead, which comes out lower because EBITDA sits above interest and tax. Pick one and use it consistently.
Above about 90% over five years is a good sign in a mature business. Well below that needs an explanation, and often there's a perfectly good one.
What pushes it up, what pulls it down
Read the left column carefully. Conversion above 100% isn't automatically good news. A company that spends less than its depreciation year after year will convert beautifully until its equipment wears out.
Five years, two companies
Thornbury, an illustrative maker of household cleaning products, converts 104% over five years (1,140 ÷ 1,100), and no single year strays far from 100%. Nothing exciting. That's the point.
Avonmore, an illustrative pump maker, grew net income about 17% a year and was a market favourite. Its five-year conversion is 28% (290 ÷ 1,050), and the yearly figure slid from 80% to below zero. Over the same years its days sales outstanding rose from 55 to 85 while capex held steady. Profit and cash moving in opposite directions for five straight years is the classic warning.
The serial acquirer's flattering ratio
Linwood Data (illustrative) buys a small software company most years. This year it reported net income of $100 million after $60 million of amortisation on intangibles it had acquired. Free cash flow was $170 million, a conversion of 170%. It also spent $400 million on acquisitions.
Both sides of the ratio are flattered by the deals. The amortisation lowers profit without costing cash, and the acquisitions cost cash without counting as capex. If buying companies is how Linwood grows, treat acquisitions as its capex. On that basis its free cash flow was minus $230 million.
Sloan's accrual anomaly
In 1996 Richard Sloan published a study in The Accounting Review that split the earnings of US companies from 1962 to 1991 into a cash part and an accrual part. The accrual part was less persistent: profit built on accruals was more likely to fade the next year than profit backed by cash.
Share prices didn't seem to notice. Investors priced earnings as if both parts were equally durable, and a portfolio that bought the companies with the lowest accruals and sold short those with the highest earned roughly 10% in the following year, before costs.
Later research found that the excess return had largely gone from US shares by the 2000s, possibly because hedge funds traded it away. The finding about persistence is the part to keep. When profit runs well ahead of cash, expect it to be harder to repeat.
When the ratio stops working
- Small or negative profit. Divide by net income near zero and the ratio swings to absurd values; below zero it means nothing. Compare free cash flow with revenue instead.
- Young growers. A company building capacity ahead of demand will convert poorly for years, by design. Judge it on what the new capacity earns.
- Cycles. Working capital releases cash as sales shrink, so conversion can look best in the worst year.
- Banks and insurers. Free cash flow doesn't mean much for them, for the reasons in lesson 1.
A quality-of-earnings check
- Add up five years of free cash flow and of net income, and divide. Around 90% or more is reassuring for a mature business.
- Compare receivables growth with revenue growth. Receivables racing ahead is the most common early warning.
- Do the same with inventory against cost of goods sold.
- If DPO jumped, read the supplier finance note.
- Subtract stock-based pay from free cash flow, and check the share count.
- If the company buys its growth, count the acquisitions as capex.
FCF conversion on Dividend Line
The Chartroom's Cash Machine chapter has an FCF / net income chart: free cash flow divided by net income for each period, with a reference line at 100%. A badge grades the latest value, Cash-backed at 90% or more, Watch from 70%, Weak below that, and the reading line counts how many periods came in above 100%. Periods with a loss are left out.
On the Financial Flows tab, the DuPont & Quality Audit card gives the cash version (operating cash flow ÷ net income) for the latest year. The Examination on the Summary tab includes the Beneish M-score, one of whose eight inputs is total accruals; our Financial Fortress course explains it.
The screener has no conversion filter, but its cash measures make a decent first pass. FCF margin and the Positive free cash flow switch sit in the Profitability group and use the last twelve months; FCF growth sits in the Growth group and uses annual figures. None of them subtracts stock-based pay.
Takeaways
Sources for this lesson
- Richard G. Sloan, "Do Stock Prices Fully Reflect Information in Accruals and Cash Flows about Future Earnings?", The Accounting Review 71(3), 1996, pp. 289–315
- Jeremiah Green, John Hand and Mark Soliman, "Going, Going, Gone? The Apparent Demise of the Accruals Anomaly", Management Science 57(5), 2011
- Howard Schilit, Jeremy Perler and Yoni Engelhart, Financial Shenanigans (4th edition, 2018)