Earnings vs operating cash flow
Net income and operating cash flow describe the same year and rarely agree. The gap between them has three sources, and reading it tells you how much of the profit you can lean on.
Profit runs on a different clock
Accountants book revenue once a company has delivered what it was paid for. When the money arrives is a separate question. A machine maker that ships $10 million of equipment in December records the sale that year, even if the customer pays in March. Costs work the same way. A delivery van bought for $50,000 doesn't hit profit all at once; it's spread over its useful life as depreciation, say $10,000 a year for five years.
This is accrual accounting, and it's the right way to measure a year's performance. The catch is that it rests on estimates (how long the van lasts, whether the customer will pay), and estimates can be optimistic. Cash keeps its own clock. It either reached the bank account or it didn't.
Over a long enough stretch the two clocks have to agree. Every sale is eventually collected or written off, and every van is eventually paid for and worn out. In any single year they can be far apart, and the size and direction of the gap say something about the business.
Three sources of the gap
The cash flow statement starts at net income and adjusts it back to cash. Our annual report course goes through it line by line. For reading purposes the adjustments fall into three groups.
- Non-cash charges. Depreciation, amortisation, impairments and stock-based compensation all reduced profit without any cash leaving that year, so they're added back. Deferred tax belongs here too: tax booked as an expense but not yet paid.
- Gains and losses that belong elsewhere. Sell a warehouse for more than its book value and the profit on the sale lands in net income. The cash from the sale shows up under investing, so the gain is taken out of operating cash flow.
- Working capital. Money tied up in receivables and inventory, less money owed to suppliers. When receivables and stock grow faster than payables, cash falls behind profit. Lesson 3 is about nothing else.
Same profit, very different cash
Two illustrative companies each report $100 million of net income this year.
Ferncliff makes tents and camping gear. Most of its gap is depreciation, which is normal for a company with factories, and working capital barely moved.
Moorgate sells factory automation kit. Its revenue grew 8%, from $900 million to $972 million, while receivables jumped 45%, from $122 million to $177 million. Either customers are taking longer to pay or Moorgate is booking sales earlier than it used to. Only a third of its profit arrived as cash, and $12 million of the profit came from selling a building.
Which way should the gap point?
For a mature company with steady sales, operating cash flow usually sits above net income, because depreciation is added back and working capital doesn't grow much. That's the normal state of affairs, and on its own it shouldn't impress you.
A fast-growing company can honestly show the opposite. If sales rise 30% a year, receivables and stock rise with them and tie up cash every year. The question is whether the gap matches the growth. When receivables grow more than five times as fast as sales, as at Moorgate, growth alone doesn't explain it. Our lesson on the notes works through a warning sign of exactly this kind.
One year proves little. A big order shipped on 30 December can swing receivables by itself. Put five years of both lines side by side and pay attention when the gap widens year after year.
Operating cash flow can be dressed up too
Cash is harder to fake than profit. It can still be flattered, and a few common moves push operating cash flow up without making the business any better.
- Stretching suppliers. Pay suppliers later and operating cash flow rises for a year. Lesson 3 covers this and its bank-funded cousin, supplier finance.
- Selling receivables. A company can sell its invoices to a bank (factoring) and collect cash today instead of in 60 days. It's a one-off boost that can't be repeated next year.
- Capitalising costs. Wages spent building software, or interest paid during construction, can go on the balance sheet as assets. The cash then leaves through investing, so operating cash flow looks better. Free cash flow, which subtracts capex, catches most of this.
- Leases under IFRS. Since 2019, IFRS 16 has made companies split each lease payment. The part that repays the lease liability goes under financing; the interest part goes under operating or financing, depending on the company's policy. Before 2019 the whole rent sat in operating cash flow. A European retailer with 600 rented shops can therefore show far higher operating cash flow and free cash flow than its rent bill suggests. US companies reporting under ASC 842 still put operating lease payments in operating cash flow. To compare the two, subtract the lease principal repayments from the IFRS company's free cash flow.
The bridge on Dividend Line
The Financial Flows tab on each company page draws the cash flow statement as a flow chart. Its operating section starts from net income and adds the reconciling items as separate bands: D&A, stock-based comp, deferred tax, the change in working capital and other non-cash items. Very small items are folded into an Other band. You can switch between annual and quarterly statements and pick the period.
Beside the chart, a Cash Conversion panel puts net income, operating cash flow and free cash flow on bars of the same scale and gives operating cash flow divided by net income. Further down the tab, the DuPont & Quality Audit card reads the same ratio from the latest annual accounts. At 110% or more it calls the earnings high quality. Between 90% and 110% it says profit and cash track each other closely, and below 90% it says profit is running ahead of cash and points you at working capital and accruals.
For the longer view, the Financials tab has a Cash Flow section with operating cash flow, the net income it starts from, the D&A and stock-based compensation add-backs and the change in working capital, year by year.
Takeaways
Sources for this lesson
- Martin Fridson and Fernando Alvarez, Financial Statement Analysis: A Practitioner's Guide (4th edition, 2011)
- IASB, IAS 7 Statement of Cash Flows, and IFRS 16 Leases (2016); FASB, ASC 842 Leases (2016)
- Howard Schilit, Jeremy Perler and Yoni Engelhart, Financial Shenanigans (4th edition, 2018), on cash flow shenanigans