Chapter six of six · The Annual Report, End to End

The notes: where the real story hides

The pages after the statements, what to look for in each note, and the warning signs that something is off.

LevelBeginnerReading8 minutesPlates5
§ I

The part most people skip

The notes to the financial statements are where the company explains what's inside each number. They're audited, same as the statements. They're also long, dense and full of tables, which is why most investors skip them, and why reading them is one of the cheapest edges a patient investor can get.

Start with the first note or two, usually titled 'Summary of significant accounting policies'. It tells you how the company recognises revenue, over how many years it depreciates assets, how it values inventory and what it counts as cash. Then read the 'critical accounting estimates' section in MD&A, which lists the judgements management thinks could move the numbers most. Between them, those two tell you where to point your attention.

You don't need every note every year. We always read the ones in this lesson, plus any note tied to a line that moved a lot.

§ II

How the money comes in, and from where

Revenue recognition under US GAAP follows ASC 606, and IFRS 15 is almost identical. It works in five steps:

  1. Identify the contract with the customer.
  2. Identify the separate promises in it, called performance obligations.
  3. Work out the transaction price.
  4. Allocate that price across the promises.
  5. Recognise revenue as each promise is satisfied, either at a point in time or over time.

The revenue note shows how the company applies those steps to its own business. Look for the split by product, region and customer type, whether revenue is recognised at a point in time or over time, and the 'remaining performance obligations' figure, which is contracted revenue not yet earned. Big contract assets (revenue booked but not yet billable) are where management's judgement does the most work.

The segment note (ASC 280) is often the most useful page in the filing. Segments follow the way management runs the business internally, so you see revenue and profit for each part the way the chief executive sees them. A 2023 update to the standard, ASU 2023-07, also requires companies to disclose significant expenses for each segment. This is where you find out that one division makes most of the money while another quietly loses it.

Segment A revenue800
Segment A operating income200
Segment A operating margin25%
Segment B revenue400
Segment B operating income(20)
Segment B operating margin−5%
Corporate costs(40)
Total operating income140

The consolidated income statement shows an 11.7% operating margin. The segment note tells you it's really a very good business attached to a loss-making one.

Plate I. Segment note, simplified (illustrative, $ millions)
§ III

Stock pay, leases and debt maturities

The stock-based compensation note (ASC 718) shows what employees were granted during the year, how the awards were valued, and the cost still to come: 'unrecognised compensation cost' for awards already granted, and the average period over which it will hit the income statement. Divide the year's expense by revenue and track it. If it keeps rising as a share of revenue, owners are handing over a bigger slice of the business in stock each year.

The lease note gives a table of future lease payments by year, with a line that takes off the interest to arrive at the liability on the balance sheet. It also separates operating leases from finance leases. For a retailer or restaurant chain, lease commitments are often the biggest fixed obligation it has, and they belong in your picture of its debt.

The debt note lists the bonds and loans with their interest rates and maturities, plus a schedule of how much falls due in each of the next five years and after. Covenants, the conditions lenders attach (a maximum ratio of debt to EBITDA, say), are usually described here or in MD&A.

Year 150
Year 275
Year 3600
Year 4100
Year 50
Thereafter400
Total debt1,225

A wall like Year 3 is manageable if the company has the cash or easy access to new loans. It turns dangerous if it has to refinance in a bad credit market at a much higher rate. Check cash and free cash flow against the biggest year.

Plate II. Debt maturity schedule (illustrative, $ millions)
§ IV

Contingencies, commitments and related parties

Some obligations never reach the balance sheet, or only partly. Contingencies (ASC 450) are the main one. A possible loss from a lawsuit, an environmental clean-up or a tax dispute is recorded as a liability only when it's probable and the amount can be reasonably estimated. If it's reasonably possible but short of probable, the company only has to describe it in the notes. A large lawsuit can sit in a note with no number on the balance sheet at all.

Likelihood of lossWhat the company has to do
Probable, and the amount can be reasonably estimatedRecord a liability and an expense
Probable, but no reasonable estimate is possibleDescribe it in the notes
Reasonably possibleDescribe it in the notes, with an estimate or range where it can give one
RemoteUsually nothing, though some guarantees must still be disclosed
Plate III.

The commitments note covers contracts the company has signed but not yet paid for: purchase obligations with suppliers, minimum payments under long-term contracts, guarantees of someone else's debt. These look harmless in good years and hurt in bad ones.

Related-party transactions (ASC 850, and Item 13 of the 10-K) are deals between the company and its insiders: an executive's family firm supplying services, a director who owns the building the company rents, loans to managers. Small ones are common and often harmless. Large or growing ones are a governance warning, because the people approving the deal sit on both sides of it.

§ V

Non-GAAP figures and 'one-time' items

Most companies now report 'adjusted' figures alongside GAAP ones: adjusted EBITDA, adjusted EPS, free cash flow defined their own way. These are allowed. SEC rules (Regulation G and Item 10(e) of Regulation S-K) require a reconciliation to the closest GAAP measure, and in filings the GAAP number has to get equal or greater prominence. The reconciliation table is the part to read, because it lists exactly what management would like you to ignore.

GAAP diluted EPS$2.00
Add: restructuring charges$0.30
Add: amortisation of acquired intangibles$0.40
Add: stock-based compensation$0.50
Less: tax effect of the adjustments($0.25)
Adjusted EPS$2.95

Adjusted EPS comes out 48% above GAAP EPS. Some adjustments are defensible. Stock-based pay is an ordinary cost of running the business.

Plate IV. From GAAP to adjusted EPS (illustrative)

Watch for one-time items that come back every year. A restructuring charge in one year is believable. Restructuring charges in seven of the last eight years are a cost of doing business and should be treated as one. A simple test: add up everything excluded over five years and compare it with five years of GAAP earnings.

§ VI

Warning signs that deserve a closer look

None of these proves anything on its own. Each is a reason to read more carefully. Howard Schilit's Financial Shenanigans is the classic catalogue of ways companies flatter their numbers, and most of the tricks leave traces in the notes. Two ratios catch a lot of them.

Days sales outstanding (DSO)
Accounts receivable ÷ Revenue × 365
How many days of sales are still waiting to be collected.
Days inventory outstanding (DIO)
Inventory ÷ Cost of goods sold × 365
How many days of stock the company is carrying.
Revenue, Year 1500
Revenue, Year 2550 (+10%)
Receivables, end of Year 160
Receivables, end of Year 290 (+50%)
DSO, Year 144 days
DSO, Year 260 days

Customers are taking about two weeks longer to pay, or the company is booking sales early (shipping ahead of demand, or offering long payment terms to hit a target). Either way, that revenue is lower quality than it looks.

Plate V. Receivables outrunning revenue (illustrative, $ millions)
  • Receivables growing much faster than revenue, as in the example.
  • Inventory days rising year after year, which can mean products aren't selling and a write-down is coming.
  • Costs moved from the income statement onto the balance sheet. Capitalised software, capitalised customer acquisition costs and unusually long depreciation lives all push expenses into later years. WorldCom's fraud involved booking billions of dollars of ordinary line costs as capital spending.
  • Cash from operations persistently below net income, especially while profits are rising.
  • 'One-time' charges that keep recurring, and adjusted earnings that sit far above GAAP every year.
  • A change of auditor, disclosed in an 8-K under Item 4.01, especially after a disagreement. An 8-K under Item 4.02 says earlier statements can no longer be relied on, which means a restatement is coming.
  • A material weakness in internal controls, reported in Item 9A.
  • Related-party deals that keep growing, or a CFO who leaves just before or after year-end.
Compare cash conversion, margins and balance sheet strength across companies, then read the notes of anything that looks off.Screen for warning signs →
§ VII

What to remember

  1. The notes are audited and explain every big number; start with the accounting policies and the critical estimates.
  2. The segment note shows which parts of the business actually make the money.
  3. Read the non-GAAP reconciliation line by line, and treat recurring 'one-time' charges as normal costs.
  4. Receivables outpacing revenue, rising inventory days, capitalised costs and auditor changes are all reasons to dig deeper.
Ex libris · next course, DL 201

Valuation Ratios

You've reached the end of The Annual Report, End to End. DL 201 · Ratios & Metrics starts here. About 22 minutes.

Turn the page →
The Annual Report, End to End · 6 of 6 chapters
Notes
  1. FASB Accounting Standards Codification (ASC 280, 450, 606, 718, 842, 850), Financial Accounting Standards Board
  2. Financial Shenanigans, Howard Schilit (1993)
  3. Educational content only. Not investment advice.