Chapter two of six · The Annual Report, End to End

The income statement, line by line

Every line from revenue down to earnings per share, what each one tells you as an owner, and where the numbers like to hide things.

LevelBeginnerReading8 minutesPlates2
§ I

Top line to bottom line

The income statement covers a period of time, usually a year or a quarter, and answers one question: did the business earn more than it spent? It starts with revenue at the top (the 'top line'), takes off costs in layers, and ends with net income at the bottom. Each layer ends in a subtotal, and each subtotal tells you something different, so it pays to stop at every one.

One idea sits under the whole statement. US GAAP uses accrual accounting: revenue is recorded when it's earned and costs when they're incurred, whenever the cash actually moves. A customer who buys on 30-day credit counts as revenue today. Profit and cash are related, but they're separate measurements, and the cash flow statement exists to bridge them. We cover it in lesson 4.

Through this course we'll use one illustrative company, Harbour Coffee Co., a small chain of coffee shops. The numbers are made up, but they add up. You'll see this same year again on the cash flow statement in lesson 4 and across all three statements in lesson 5.

Revenue120
Cost of goods sold(48)
Gross profit72
Selling, general and administrative (includes 1 of stock-based pay)(42)
Depreciation(8)
Operating income (EBIT)22
Interest expense(2)
Income before tax20
Income tax (25%)(5)
Net income15
Weighted average shares, basic (millions)10.0
Weighted average shares, diluted (millions)10.4
Basic EPS$1.50
Diluted EPS$1.44

Numbers in brackets are deductions, which is how most filings show costs.

Plate I. Harbour Coffee Co., income statement, Year 1 (illustrative, $ millions)
§ II

Revenue, cost of goods sold and gross profit

Revenue (also 'net sales' or 'total revenues') is what customers owe for what the company delivered in the period, after returns, discounts and rebates. For an owner it's the first test of demand. Is it growing? And if so, is the growth coming from more customers, higher prices or an acquisition? The face of the statement rarely splits that out. MD&A usually does.

Cost of goods sold (or 'cost of revenue', or 'cost of sales') is the direct cost of what was sold. For Harbour that's beans, milk, cups and, depending on the company's policy, some store costs. Companies draw this line in different places, so two coffee chains with the same economics can report quite different gross margins. Check the accounting policies note before comparing them.

Gross margin
Gross profit ÷ Revenue
Harbour: 72 ÷ 120 = 60%.

Gross margin is where pricing power shows up. A company that can raise prices without losing customers holds a steady or rising gross margin even when its own costs go up. A company selling something close to a commodity sees its margin swing with input prices. We like to see ten years of gross margin before forming a view. One good year proves very little.

§ III

From gross profit to operating income

Selling, general and administrative expenses (SG&A) are the cost of running the company: head office, marketing, sales staff, IT, office rent and, at most companies, the bulk of stock-based compensation. Watch SG&A as a share of revenue. In a growing business with real advantages of scale it should drift down over the years.

Research and development gets its own line at tech, pharma and industrial companies. Under US GAAP most R&D is expensed as it's spent, even though it's often the best investment the company makes, so a heavy R&D spender can look less profitable than it really is. (IFRS lets companies capitalise some development costs once a project meets certain tests, which is one reason European and US margins don't always compare cleanly.)

Depreciation spreads the cost of physical assets, such as espresso machines and store fit-outs, over their useful lives. Amortisation does the same for intangible assets the company bought, like customer lists from an acquisition. Harbour shows depreciation as its own line. Many companies bury D&A inside cost of goods sold and SG&A, and you only see the total on the cash flow statement.

Operating income is what's left after every cost of running the business, before financing and tax. Analysts often call it EBIT, earnings before interest and taxes. The two are close cousins, though EBIT as people calculate it sometimes sweeps in non-operating items like investment gains. Operating income is the line we watch most closely, because it shows what the business earns regardless of how it's financed.

MeasureFormulaHarbour, Year 1
Gross marginGross profit ÷ Revenue60.0%
Operating marginOperating income ÷ Revenue18.3%
Net marginNet income ÷ Revenue12.5%
Effective tax rateIncome tax ÷ Income before tax25.0%
Interest coverageOperating income ÷ Interest expense11.0x
Plate II.
§ IV

Interest, tax and the bottom line

Interest expense is the cost of the company's debt. Many companies show interest income on their cash as a separate line, or net the two together. Interest coverage, operating income divided by interest expense, tells you how comfortably profits cover the debt bill. Harbour's 11 times is comfortable. Below about three times, we read the debt note very carefully.

'Other income (expense)' is a grab bag: gains and losses on investments, currency moves, some pension items. Small amounts are normal. A big number here deserves a trip to the notes, because it rarely repeats.

Income tax expense is the tax the accountants say the year's profit owes, which isn't always what was paid in cash that year (the gap shows up as deferred tax). The US federal corporate rate has been 21% since 2018, and state and foreign taxes push most effective rates above or below that. A rate that drops sharply for one year is usually a one-off, such as a settled tax dispute, and it flatters net income.

Net income is the bottom line. If the company owns less than 100% of some subsidiaries, you'll see it split between the parent's shareholders and 'noncontrolling interests'. The figure that belongs to you is net income attributable to the company's shareholders. Profit or loss from businesses being sold or shut down is reported separately as discontinued operations, and we usually set it aside when judging the business that remains.

§ V

Basic EPS, diluted EPS and the share count

Basic earnings per share
(Net income − Preferred dividends) ÷ Weighted average shares outstanding
Weighted, because the share count moves during the year as shares are issued or bought back.

Diluted EPS adds the shares that would exist if stock options, restricted stock units and convertible bonds turned into stock, as long as including them lowers EPS. So diluted EPS is never higher than basic. We use diluted. Those claims are real, and someone will end up holding those shares.

Harbour earned $15 million on 10.0 million basic shares, so basic EPS is $1.50. Employee options and units add the equivalent of 0.4 million shares on a diluted basis, which takes diluted EPS to $1.44. A gap of 4% is modest. At some software companies it's much wider.

Then look at the share count itself over five or ten years. A count that rises every year means owners are being diluted, usually by stock-based pay, and earnings have to grow faster than the share count just to keep EPS flat. A falling count means buybacks are cutting the pie into fewer slices, which lifts EPS whether or not the business grows. Our buybacks lesson covers how to tell a good buyback from a cosmetic one.

§ VI

Where the income statement misleads

Most income statements are honest. The trouble comes from reading one line, or one year, on its own. These are the traps we run into most:

  • A one-off gain. Selling a building or revaluing an investment can add a big chunk to net income. Check 'other income' and the notes before you trust a jump in EPS.
  • Growth bought with an acquisition. Total revenue rises while organic growth, from the businesses the company already owned, is flat. MD&A usually gives the split.
  • Longer useful lives. Stretching the estimated life of equipment lowers depreciation and lifts profit without a single extra sale. The accounting policies note says when it happens.
  • EPS growth from buybacks alone. If net income is flat and EPS is up 5%, the shrinking share count did the work.
  • Stock-based pay treated as free. It's a real expense under GAAP, sitting in SG&A and R&D. A company that strips it out of 'adjusted' earnings is showing you the business without part of its wage bill.
  • A tax rate that won't last. The tax note reconciles the statutory rate to the effective rate, and shows which items are temporary.
Earnings per share feeds straight into the P/E ratio. Here's how to use it, and when to distrust it.Explore valuation ratios →
§ VII

What to remember

  1. Revenue is recorded when it's earned and costs when they're incurred, so profit and cash can drift apart.
  2. Gross margin shows pricing power; operating income shows what the business earns before financing and tax.
  3. Use diluted EPS, and watch the share count over many years.
  4. Check any big jump in profit against 'other income', the tax rate and the notes before you believe it.
Ex libris · next, chapter III of 6

The balance sheet, line by line

Chapter III of The Annual Report, End to End. About 8 minutes.

Turn the page →
The Annual Report, End to End · 2 of 6 chapters
Notes
  1. Educational content only. Not investment advice.